When authority biases the holder: the case of the Costa Concordia disaster
- 18 April 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Management Decision
- Vol. 64 (3) , 1149-1169
Abstract
Purpose: We aim to understand how authority fosters overconfident behaviors and turns into myopic discretion. We explore this theoretical issue through the analysis of the decisions involved in the Costa Concordia disaster that occurred in January 2012 when the cruise ship Costa Concordia (carrying 4,229 people) hit an underwater rock and partially sank, resulting in 32 deaths. Design/methodology/approach: By employing the methodology of exploratory case studies and using data recorded by the electronic devices on the ship, which were reported in the official Sentences of the trial, we accurately reconstructed the detailed timeline of the decisions leading to the disaster. Findings: The case study illustrates the role of authority in the Captain’s overconfident decisions and shows that authority magnifies overconfidence to the point where myopic discretion substitutes rational scrutiny. Our analysis extends the classical notion of authority bias (which refers to the tendency of individuals to attribute higher credibility to the opinion of an authority) and demonstrates that authority biases not only other individuals but also the person who holds that authority. We define “authority self-bias” as the systematic tendency of an individual to attribute higher credibility to her/his own discretionary decisions if the individual holds authority. Originality/value: The case study sheds light on the pathologically reversed relations between the source of authority and its prerogatives. It shows that authority holders unwittingly substitute legitimate decisional prerogatives with confidence in making good discretionary decisions.Keywords
This publication has 60 references indexed in Scilit:
- Overconfidence and narcissism among the upper echelons: a systematic literature reviewManagement Review Quarterly, 2020
- The dark side of organizational improvisation: Lessons from the sinking of Costa ConcordiaBusiness Horizons, 2016
- Modern ships Voyage Data Recorders: A forensics perspective on the Costa Concordia shipwreckDigital Investigation, 2013
- “How can we help independent directors to escape the “obedience bias?”Journal of Management and Governance, 2008
- Overconfidence: It Depends on How, What, and Whom You AskOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1999
- The myopia of learningStrategic Management Journal, 1993
- Omission and commission in judgment and choiceJournal of Experimental Social Psychology, 1991
- Groupthink and the space shuttle challenger accident: Toward a quantitative case analysisJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 1989
- Are we all less risky and more skillful than our fellow drivers?Acta Psychologica, 1981
- Do those who know more also know more about how much they know?Organizational Behavior and Human Performance, 1977