Abstract
We survey and interview CFOs of U.S. private firms about their financial accounting practices. Although 68% of firms voluntarily use U.S. GAAP and 59% of this group obtains an audit, many firms adapt their reporting through GAAP exceptions, multiple sets of books, or qualified audit opinions. Whereas prior work emphasizes the influence of external financing providers on GAAP adoption, CFOs report that internal benefits—including improved budgeting, forecasting, and profitability analysis—are equally important. When asked about several different costs of using GAAP, more CFOs indicate that they are “not concerned” than “very concerned,” and non-GAAP users report that limited decision usefulness plays a larger role in their choice of an alternative accounting basis than concerns about implementation costs. For most accounting topics we examine, CFOs report greater perceived decision usefulness than implementation cost, with leasing as a notable exception. Collectively, our results shed light on the tradeoffs underlying financial accounting practices in a setting where accounting choices are voluntary.

This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit: