Challenging Authority During an Emergency—the Effect of a Teaching Intervention
Authors:
- 1 August 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Critical Care Medicine
- Vol. 45 (8) , e814-e820
Abstract
Previous research has shown that residents were unable to effectively challenge a superior’s wrong decision during a crisis situation, a problem that can contribute to preventable mortality. We aimed to assess whether a teaching intervention enabled residents to effectively challenge clearly wrong clinical decisions made by their staff. Following ethics board approval, second year residents were randomized to a teaching intervention targeting cognitive skills needed to challenge a superior’s decision, or a control group receiving general crisis management instruction. Two weeks later, subjects participated in a simulated crisis that presented them with opportunities to challenge clearly wrong decisions in a can’t-intubate-can’t-ventilate scenario. It was only disclosed that the staff was a confederate during the debriefing. Performances were video recorded and assessed by two raters blinded to group allocation using the modified Advocacy-Inquiry Score. Fifty residents completed the study. The interrater reliability of the modified Advocacy-Inquiry Scores (intraclass correlation coefficient = 0.87) was excellent. The median (interquartile range) best modified Advocacy-Inquiry Score was significantly better in the intervention group 5.0 (4.50–5.62 [4–6]) than in the control group 3.5 (3.0–4.75 [3–6]) (p < 0.001). A short targeted teaching intervention was effective in significantly improving residents’ ability to challenge a wrong decision by a superior. This suggests that residents are not given the proper tools to challenge authority during a life-threatening crisis situation. This educational gap can have significant implications for patients’ safety.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Crew resource management in the ICU: the need for culture changeAnnals of Intensive Care, 2012
- Poor Resident-Attending Intraoperative Communication May Compromise Patient SafetyJournal of Surgical Research, 2011
- Interprofessional simulated learning: the need for ‘sociological fidelity’Journal of Interprofessional Care, 2011
- “Renters” or “Owners”? Residentsʼ Perceptions and Behaviors Regarding Error Reduction in Teaching Hospitals: A Literature ReviewAcademic Medicine, 2009
- Systematic Review of Handoff Mnemonics LiteratureAmerican Journal of Medical Quality, 2009
- Teaching Residents the Two-Challenge Rule: A Simulation-Based Approach to Improve Education and Patient SafetySimulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare, 2009
- Teaching teamwork during the Neonatal Resuscitation Program: a randomized trialJournal of Perinatology, 2007
- Multivariate Nonparametric TestsStatistical Science, 2004
- Communication failures in the operating room: an observational classification of recurrent types and effectsQuality and Safety in Health Care, 2004
- The Efficiency of Some Nonparametric Competitors of the $t$-TestThe Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 1956