Beyond performative talk: critical observations on the radical critique of reading interview data

Authors:

Abstract
We centrally consider the question of what interview data can be used to 'say' through adialogue with advocates of the 'radical critique' of interview studies. We propose that while the critique has considerable utility in drawing attention to 'the social life of interviews' and the pervasiveness of notions of the 'romantic subject', it simultaneously goes too far in its reduction of interviews to narrative performance, and not far enough in its own critical departure from core characteristics of the romantic subject. We show how the critique leaves intact imagery of a seemingly unbridgeable divide between the experienced and the expressed, and involves a related conflation of what can be said at interview with what interviews can be used to say. We explore how the radical critique might productively be built upon via more 'synthetic' forms of research engagement, outlining alternative modes of apprehending interview data through afurther critical departure from the romantic subject. Accordingly, we advance a move beyond asole engagement with questions of how data are constructed and produced and towards how such data might otherwise be used to speak about the social world beyond the social nexus that constitutes an interview encounter.

This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit: