Impacts of biodiversity and carbon policies on the management of Norwegian forest and its ecosystem services
Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Finnish Society of Forest Science in Silva Fennica
- Vol. 58 (4)
Abstract
Measures to enhance boreal forests’ biodiversity and climate change mitigation potential are high on the policy agenda. Site productivity influences management, ecological attributes, and economic outcomes. However, national-level analyses of management implementation in response to policies considering site productivity are lacking. We analyzed impacts of a carbon policy (Carb), a biodiversity policy (Bio) and a combined biodiversity and carbon policy (BioCarb) in Norway using a simulation-optimization framework, assessing impacts on forest management, timber harvest, ecological attributes, and carbon fluxes until year 2140. Management alternatives were simulated in the single-tree simulator TreeSim before being fed into a market model NorFor to compare policy outcomes to a business-as-usual (BAU) scenario. All policies led to decreased harvests. Old forests expanded from the current 3% to cover 21% or more of the productive forest area in all scenarios. Impacts of policies depended on site productivity. On low-productive land, management under Bio mirrored BAU, while the Carb and BioCarb policies yielded more set-asides. On high-productive land, management intensity under the Carb policy was similar to BAU but the Bio and BioCarb policies resulted in more set-asides and more old forest. Thus, on low-productive land, the carbon policy showed to have the strongest impact on forest management, while on high-productive land, the biodiversity policy had the strongest impact. With geographical site-productivity gradients, the two policies exhibited different regional effects. The study shows that ex-ante analyses with appropriate tools can provide relevant information of multiple consequences beyond the stated aims which should be considered in policy design.Keywords
This publication has 83 references indexed in Scilit:
- Forest multifunctionality is not resilient to intensive forestryEuropean Journal of Forest Research, 2021
- At what carbon price forest cutting should stopJournal of Forestry Research, 2020
- Conservation value of low‐productivity forests measured as the amount and diversity of dead wood and saproxylic beetlesEcological Applications, 2018
- Impacts of forestry on boreal forests: An ecosystem services perspectiveAMBIO, 2017
- Varying rotation lengths in northern production forests: Implications for habitats provided by retention and production treesAMBIO, 2017
- Optimisation in Forest ManagementCurrent Forestry Reports, 2016
- Implementing backcasting for conservation: Determining multiple policy pathways for retaining future targets of endangered woodlands in Sydney, AustraliaBiological Conservation, 2015
- Impacts of the Kyoto Protocol on boreal forest climate change mitigationAnnals of Forest Science, 2013
- Capsis: an open software framework and community for forest growth modellingAnnals of Forest Science, 2011
- Set-asides for carbon sequestration: implications for permanence and leakageClimatic Change, 2009