A Novel Approach in Analyzing Aromaticity by Homo- and Isostructural Reactions: An ab Initio Study of Fluorobenzenes
- 1 November 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in The Journal of Physical Chemistry A
- Vol. 109 (46) , 10594-10606
Abstract
The influence of fluorine substitutions on the stability of benzene is examined by using the Hartree−Fock (HF) and MP2 models. It is conclusively demonstrated that homodesmotic reactions based on the open-chain zigzag polyenes are unsatisfactory. A comparison of the intramolecular interactions of educts and products shows that they are not well balanced. Hence, these reactions should be abandoned in discussing aromaticity. A much better vehicle for exploring aromaticity is provided by homostructural reactions, which employ cyclic monoene and diene as reference model compounds. Their heavy atoms are enforced to assume planar geometries to enable σ/π separation. The HF/cc-pVTZ calculations show that extrinsic aromaticity of benzene B ΔE(ease)B arises both from the σ- and π-contributions. They are −14.8 and −23.1 in kcal/mol, respectively, if the stockholder energy partitioning scheme is employed. This result implies that both the σ- and π-frameworks contribute to the aromatic stabilization of B, the latter being more important. The total aromatic stabilization ΔE(ease)B is −37.9 kcal/mol. Schleyer's indene−isoindene isomerization approach also strongly indicates that the decisive factor in determining the aromatic stability of the benzene moiety is the π-electron framework. The origin of extrinsic aromaticity is identified as the increased nuclear−electron attraction of both σ- and π-electrons, if 1,3-cyclohexadiene is used as a gauge compound. Further, by using a system of isostructural reactions, it is conclusively demonstrated that fluorobenzenes exhibit a remarkable additivity of the substituent effects, as far as the stability of multiply substituted benzenes is concerned. This additivity rule is so accurate that it enables delineation of the fluorine repulsions and the aromaticity defect ΔE(AD). It appears that the ΔE(AD) values increase upon sequential fluorine substitution at the next nearest (vicinal) position thus making multiply fluorinated benzenes less stable.Keywords
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Aromaticity of pericyclic reaction transition structures: magnetic evidenceJournal of Physical Organic Chemistry, 1998
- Resonance revisited: A consideration of the calculation of cyclic conjugation energiesJournal of Computational Chemistry, 1997
- Aromaticity and Antiaromaticity in Five‐Membered C4H4X Ring Systems: “Classical” and “Magnetic” Concepts May Not Be “Orthogonal”Angewandte Chemie International Edition, 1995
- Why do some molecules have symmetry different from that expected?Journal of Chemical Education, 1989
- Ground States of Conjugated Molecules. III. Classical Polyenes1Journal of the American Chemical Society, 1965
- Heats of Organic Reactions. IV. Hydrogenation of Some Dienes and of BenzeneJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1936
- Heats of Organic Reactions III. Hydrogenation of Some Higher OlefinsJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1936
- Quantentheoretische Beitr ge zum Problem der aromatischen und unges ttigten Verbindungen. IIIThe European Physical Journal A, 1932
- Quantentheoretische Beitr ge zum BenzolproblemThe European Physical Journal A, 1931
- Bemerkung zum VirialsatzThe European Physical Journal A, 1930