A multi‐level approach for multi‐objective optimization in process eco‐design
Open Access
- 22 December 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Environmental Progress & Sustainable Energy
- Vol. 45 (3)
Abstract
This work addresses a central challenge in process eco‐design: how to efficiently integrate environmental and economic criteria—often conflicting—into early design stages while managing the high dimensionality of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) indicators. To this end, we propose a generic six‐level multi‐objective methodology combining process simulation, LCA, a modified NSGA‐II genetic algorithm, and multiple criteria decision‐making (MCDM) models (ELECTRE, PROMETHEE, M‐TOPSIS). The approach is applied to the hydrodealkylation of toluene (HDA) for benzene production. Starting from a set of five criteria (four environmental end‐points and economic performance), later expanded to 14 environmental mid‐points, the method identifies redundant indicators and reduces the optimization to the most influential objectives. Results show that a bi‐objective optimization (economic performance vs. human‐health impacts) is sufficient to represent trade‐offs previously captured by the full 14‐indicator space. Quantitatively, the optimized solutions achieve 12%–18% reductions in environmental end‐point impacts relative to single‐objective economic optimization, without increasing operating costs. Mid‐point results indicate that ozone layer depletion is the dominant contributor among human‐health categories, guiding the formulation of a refined optimization problem. MCDM techniques consistently identify similar compromise solutions, confirming the robustness of the reduced‐criteria strategy. Overall, this framework demonstrates that combining LCA, multi‐objective optimization, and MCDM into a structured multi‐level workflow enables engineers to reduce problem complexity while achieving environmentally improved designs that remain economically viable.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Multi-objective optimization and multi-criteria decision making aided by numerical method: Framework and a case study of Malaysia and South AfricaEnergy Conversion and Management, 2022
- Demand response‐based operation of a hybrid renewable energy system with energy storage by multi‐objective optimization and multi‐criteria decision makingEnvironmental Progress & Sustainable Energy, 2022
- Machine learning aided multi-objective optimization and multi-criteria decision making: Framework and two applications in chemical engineeringComputers & Chemical Engineering, 2022
- Development of an ecodesign framework for food manufacturing including process flowsheeting and multiple-criteria decision-making: Application to milk evaporationFood and Bioproducts Processing, 2022
- An integrated optimization methodology for heat transfer enhancement: A case study on nanofluid flow in a pipe equipped with insertsInternational Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2021
- A new PROMETHEE-based approach applied within a framework for conflict analysis in Evidence Theory integrating three conflict measuresExpert Systems with Applications, 2018
- Coupling life cycle assessment with process simulation for ecodesign of chemical processesEnvironmental Progress & Sustainable Energy, 2017
- Economic and environmental strategies for process designComputers & Chemical Engineering, 2012
- Multiobjective genetic algorithm strategies for electricity production from generation IV nuclear technologyEnergy Conversion and Management, 2010
- IMPACT 2002+: A new life cycle impact assessment methodologyThe International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment, 2003