Direct Estimate of the Strength of Conjugation and Hyperconjugation by the Energy Decomposition Analysis Method
- 12 April 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Chemistry – A European Journal
- Vol. 12 (13) , 3617-3629
Abstract
The intrinsic strength of π interactions in conjugated and hyperconjugated molecules has been calculated using density functional theory by energy decomposition analysis (EDA) of the interaction energy between the conjugating fragments. The results of the EDA of the trans‐polyenes H2CCH(HCCH)nCHCH2 (n=1–3) show that the strength of π conjugation for each CC moiety is higher than in trans‐1,3‐butadiene. The absolute values for the conjugation between SiSi π bonds are around two‐thirds of the conjugation between CC bonds but the relative contributions of ΔEπ to ΔEorb in the all‐silicon systems are higher than in the carbon compounds. The π conjugation between CC and CO or CNH bonds in H2CCHC(H)O and H2CCHC(H)NH is comparable to the strength of the conjugation between CC bonds. The π conjugation in H2CCHC(R)O decreases when R=Me, OH, and NH2 while it increases when R=halogen. The hyperconjugation in ethane is around a quarter as strong as the π conjugation in ethyne. Very strong hyperconjugation is found in the central CC bonds in cubylcubane and tetrahedranyltetrahedrane. The hyperconjugation in substituted ethanes X3CCY3 (X,Y=Me, SiH3, F, Cl) is stronger than in the parent compound particularly when X,Y=SiH3 and Cl. The hyperconjugation in donor–acceptor‐substituted ethanes may be very strong; the largest ΔEπ value was calculated for (SiH3)3CCCl3 in which the hyperconjugation is stronger than the conjugation in ethene. The breakdown of the hyperconjugation in X3CCY3 shows that donation of the donor‐substituted moiety to the acceptor group is as expected the most important contribution but the reverse interaction is not negligible. The relative strengths of the π interactions between two CC double bonds, one CC double bond and CH3 or CMe3 substituents, and between two CH3 or CMe3 groups, which are separated by one CC single bond, are in a ratio of 4:2:1. Very strong hyperconjugation is found in HCCC(SiH3)3 and HCCCCl3. The extra stabilization of alkenes and alkynes with central multiple bonds over their terminal isomers coming from hyperconjugation is bigger than the total energy difference between the isomeric species. The hyperconjugation in MeC(R)O is half as strong as the conjugation in H2CCHC(R)O and shows the same trend for different substituents R. Bond energies and lengths should not be used as indicators of the strength of hyperconjugation because the effect of σ interactions and electrostatic forces may compensate for the hyperconjugative effect.Keywords
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Nature of the Chemical Bond Revisited: An Energy‐Partitioning Analysis of Nonpolar BondsChemistry – A European Journal, 2005
- Rebuttal to the Bickelhaupt–Baerends Case for Steric Repulsion Causing the Staggered Conformation of EthaneAngewandte Chemie, 2003
- Valence-Shell Charge Concentrations and Electron Delocalization in Alkyllithium Complexes: Negative Hyperconjugation and Agostic BondingChemistry – A European Journal, 2002
- Enthalpy of hydrogenation of the hexadienes and cis- and trans-1,3,5-hexatrieneThe Journal of Organic Chemistry, 1992
- A survey of Hammett substituent constants and resonance and field parametersChemical Reviews, 1991
- Mechanistic studies of the far-UV photochemical ring-opening and cleavage reactions of 1,1-dimethyl-1-silacyclobut-2-eneOrganometallics, 1989
- Reactions of 1,1-dimethylsilabutadiene. Stereospecific 4 + 2 and nonstereospecific 2 + 2 cycloadditionsJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1988
- Roothaan-Hartree-Fock-Slater atomic wave functionsAtomic Data and Nuclear Data Tables, 1981
- Heats of Organic Reactions. VIII. Some Further Hydrogenations, Including Those of Some AcetylenesJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1939
- Heats of Organic Reactions. IV. Hydrogenation of Some Dienes and of BenzeneJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1936