Educating, training, and exercising for infectious disease control with emphasis on cross-border settings: an integrative review
Authors:
- Doret de RooijDRDoret de Rooij
- Christos HadjichristodoulouChristos Hadjichristodoulou
- Varvara A. MouchtouriVarvara A. Mouchtouri
- Jörg RaabJRJörg Raab
- Aura TimenATAura Timen
- for the EU HEALTHY GATEWAYS Joint Action consortiumFCfor the EU HEALTHY GATEWAYS Joint Action consortium
Open Access
- 3 September 2020
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Globalization and Health
- Vol. 16 (1) , 1-49
Abstract
Introduction: Points of entry and other border regions educate, train, and exercise (ETEs) their staff to improve preparedness and response to cross-border health threats. However, no conclusive knowledge of these ETEs’ effectiveness exists. This study aimed to review the literature on ETEs in infectious disease control concerning their methods and effect, with an emphasis on cross-border settings and methods that enlarge ETEs’ reach. Methodology: We systematically searched for studies in the databases Embase, Medline, Web of Science, PsycInfo, ERIC, and Cinahl. After successively screening titles and abstracts, full-texts, and citations, 62 studies were included using in- and exclusion criteria. Data were extracted using a data-extraction form. Quality assessment was performed. We developed a theoretical framework based on which we analyzed the ETE context (target group, recruitment, autonomy, training needs), input (topic, trainers, development and quality of materials), process (design, duration, interval, goals), evaluation (pre-, post- follow-up tests), and outcome (reaction, learning, behavior, and system). Results: We found a limited number of published evaluations of ETEs in general (n = 62) and of cross-border settings (n = 5) in particular. The quality assessment resulted in seven ETE methodologies and 23 evaluations with a ‘good’ score. Both general studies and those in a cross-border setting contain a low-moderate detail level on context, input, and process. The evaluations were performed on reaction (n = 45), learning (n = 45), behavior (n = 9) and system (n = 4), mainly using pre- and post-tests (n = 22). Online learning methods have a high potential in enlarging the reach and are effective, particularly in combination with offline training. Training-of-trainer approaches are effective for learning; new ETEs were developed by 20–44% of participants until six months after the initial training. Conclusion: Our study reveals a limited number of publications on ETEs in infectious disease control. Studies provide few details on methodology, and use mainly short-term evaluations and low level outcomes. We call for more extensive, higher-level evaluation standards of ETEs, and an easy and sustainable way to exchange evaluations within the workforce of infectious disease control in cross-border settings. The theoretical framework developed in this study could guide future development and evaluation of ETEs in infectious disease control.Keywords
Funding Information
- Consumer Programme (801493)
- Rijksinstituut voor Volksgezondheid en Milieu
This publication has 75 references indexed in Scilit:
- Preoperative assessment and treatment of appendiceal mucocele complicated by acute torsion: a case reportBMC Research Notes, 2014
- Immersive Simulation Education: A Novel Approach to Pandemic Preparedness and ResponsePublic Health Nursing, 2013
- Southeastern Center for Emerging Biologic Threats Tabletop Exercise: Foodborne Toxoplasmosis Outbreak on College CampusesBiosecurity and Bioterrorism: Biodefense Strategy, Practice, and Science, 2012
- Exercises in Emergency Preparedness for Health Professionals in Community ClinicsJournal of Community Health, 2010
- Development and evaluation of a leadership training program for public health emergency response: results from a Chinese studyBMC Public Health, 2008
- Designing and conducting tabletop exercises to assess public health preparedness for manmade and naturally occurring biological threatsBMC Public Health, 2007
- A Pilot Hybrid Internet/Classroom-based Communicable Disease Continuing Education Course for Public Health Nurses in North CarolinaJournal of Public Health Management & Practice, 2005
- The Texas Training Initiative for Emergency Response (T-TIER)Journal of Public Health Management & Practice, 2005
- Simulating Public Health Response to a Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) EventJournal of Public Health Management & Practice, 2005
- Coastal TerrorismJournal of Public Health Management & Practice, 2005