Gambling for growth or settling for survival: the dilemma of the small business adviser
Author:
- 1 December 2000
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development
- Vol. 7 (4) , 305-314
Abstract
The paper questions aspects of the UK government’s policy to target small firm support on fast‐growing firms – to maximise its employment impact. The paper explores the tension between advice likely to increase growth and risk‐taking and advice likely to ensure firm survival in the turbulent small and medium‐sized enterprises sector. The research data derive from 24 semi‐structured interviews and a group interview of ten business advisers in the West Midlands region collected between autumn 1996 and spring 1997, and a national survey of 175 Business Link personal business advisers (PBAs) conducted in April 1998. Interviewees responded to a prompt asking for advice to a fast‐growing firm. The paper compares qualitative interview responses from a wide variety of West Midlands business advisers with questionnaire responses from PBAs. The paper suggests that the advice given by accountants and bank managers differs little from that given by Business Link’s PBAs. The paper will argue that advisers including PBAs, offer risk‐averse advice and support to small firms. Present business advice might reduce insolvency rather than increase the number of fast‐growth firms. The risk‐averse nature of advice, reflecting the adviser’s clientele, undermines policies designed to increase the number of fast‐growth companies. It concludes that advice will often be inconsistent with the growth‐oriented aim of government policy.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- The use of external business advice by SMEs in BritainEntrepreneurship & Regional Development, 1999
- The nature of the client‐personal business advisor relationship within Business LinkJournal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 1999
- The evolution of managerial information, control and decision‐making processes in small growth‐oriented service sector businesses: exploratory lessons from four cases of successJournal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 1998
- Targeted support for new and young businesses: the case of North Yorkshire TEC’s “Backing Winners” programmeJournal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 1998
- Policy, prediction and growth: picking start‐up winners?Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 1998
- Business link partnerships and small firm policy: A response to Bryson, Churchward and DanielsRegional Studies, 1997
- Strategic initiatives and small business performance: an exploratory analysis of Irish companiesEntrepreneurship & Regional Development, 1997
- DEVELOPING PERSONAL BUSINESS ADVISERS: AN INSIDER'S VIEWJournal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 1995
- The role of new firms: Births, deaths and job generationStrategic Management Journal, 1986
- Street-Level Bureaucracy and the Analysis of Urban ReformUrban Affairs Review, 1971