Stuck in the middle? Community development, community engagement and the dangerous business of learning for democracy
Author:
- 24 February 2011
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Community Development Journal
- Vol. 46 (Supplement) , ii128-ii146
Abstract
Historically, community development has been centrally concerned with democracy: in many contexts, its professional legitimacy has been justified by its strategic position as mediator in the relationship between the state and its citizens, through various forms of participation and community engagement. Whilst community development offers opportunities for extending and deepening democracy, such activity is always framed and regulated by the changing imperatives of policy. This has inevitably produced contradictions and tensions which, in turn, have framed the possibilities and constraints for practice. Negotiating these has always been a core challenge for practitioners. This article argues that contemporary community development, as both the agent and subject of modernization processes, has become seriously undermined in meeting this challenge. There is a danger that this leaves community workers stuck in the middle, as distinct from strategically positioned, between marketized state policy and democratic politics. The challenge for community development is how people can learn to be engaged – and, where necessary, to dissent – as actors in democratic politics in a context in which they are positioned as passive consumers, problematic objects of policy or resources for the diminishing welfare state. This will involve exposing the ways in which democracy is framed in policy and re-creating forms of purposeful practice that can act as a filter for sifting and sorting those values and practices which are in danger of erasing the democratic potential of community development.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reconciling agency with structure: The contradictions and paradoxes of capacity building in Wales' 2000—2006 Objective 1 programmeCritical Social Policy, 2009
- Unpacking 'Participation': models, meanings and practicesCommunity Development Journal, 2008
- Respectable or Respectful? (In)civility and the CityUrban Studies, 2006
- Raising expectations or dashing hopes?: Well-being and participation in disadvantaged areasCommunity Development Journal, 2006
- New Labour’s citizens: activated, empowered, responsibilized, abandoned?Critical Social Policy, 2005
- ‘The grit in the oyster’: Community development workers in a modernizing local authorityCommunity Development Journal, 2005
- From recognition to support: Community development workers in the United KingdomCommunity Development Journal, 2005
- Manufactured Civil Society: Counting the CostCritical Social Policy, 2004
- Ethnicity and the Multicultural City: Living with DiversityEnvironment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 2002
- Community Development in a Global ContextCommunity Development Journal, 1998