In the context of heightened economic uncertainty in the United States, inflation has become not only a central macroeconomic issue but also a contested public narrative made up by those who live it, the framing of the media and the press release of institutions. To analyze how Americans construct an evaluation of Federal Reserve communication and monetary policy, what is the role of Americans’ perception of inflation, media consumption habits and trust in the Federal Reserve, this study examines how the major economic indicators influence Americans’ perceptions and evaluation of Federal Reserve policy and communication. The research uses a robust set of statistical analysis such as chi square tests, ANOVA, independent t test and multiple regression using survey data from 400 U.S.-based respondents to study the relationship between the media narratives, inflation sentiment and institutional credibility. Results show the path to trusting the Federal Reserve is clear: through clear communication, correct reporting by the media and firsthand experience with inflation. Respondents who consumed the media with high academic or governmental presence and evaluated the Fed’s messaging as transparent were more likely to report high institutional trust and support raising the interest rates. More inflation or a greater use of social media, made individuals less trusting, more skeptical and more populist, with greater demands for public influence over monetary decisions. These results highlight the importance of narrative in determining legitimacy in an economy and provide key lessons for central bankers and policymakers aiming to project legitimacy in highly polarized environments and fragmented media ecosystems. The study points the Federal Reserve to the urgent requirement of adopting more adaptive, more inclusive and more audience aware communication strategies to not only cultivate but also to maintain trust in its policy making and to optimize alignment.