Accuracy and clinical effectiveness of risk prediction tools for pressure injury occurrence: An umbrella review
Preprint
Abstract
Background Pressure injuries (PIs) pose a substantial healthcare burden and incur significant costs worldwide. Several risk prediction models to allow timely implementation of preventive measures and potentially reduce healthcare system burden are available and in use. The ability of risk prediction tools to correctly identify those at high risk of PI (prognostic accuracy) and to have a clinically significant impact on patient management and outcomes (effectiveness) is not clear. We aimed to evaluate the prognostic accuracy and clinical effectiveness of risk prediction tools for PI, and to identify gaps in the literature. Methods and Findings The umbrella review was conducted according to Cochrane guidance. MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, EPISTEMONIKOS, Google Scholar and reference lists were searched to identify relevant systematic reviews. Risk of bias was assessed using adapted AMSTAR-2 criteria. Results were described narratively. We identified 16 reviews that assessed prognostic accuracy and 10 that assessed clinical effectiveness of risk prediction tools for PI. The 16 reviews of prognostic accuracy evaluated 63 tools (39 scales and 24 machine learning models), with the Braden, Norton, Waterlow, Cubbin-Jackson scales (and modifications thereof) the most evaluated tools. Meta-analyses from a focused set of included reviews showed that the scales had sensitivities and specificities ranging from 53%-97% and 46%-84%, respectively. Only 2/16 reviews performed appropriate statistical synthesis and quality assessment. One review assessing machine learning based algorithms reported high prognostic accuracy estimates, but some of which were sourced from the same data within which the models were developed, leading to potentially overoptimistic results. Two randomised trials assessing the effect of PI risk assessment tools on incidence of PIs were identified from the 10 systematic reviews of clinical effectiveness; both were included in a Cochrane review and assessed as high risk of bias. Both trials found no evidence of an effect on PI incidence. Conclusions Our findings underscore the lack of high-quality evidence for the accuracy of risk prediction tools for PI. There is no reliable evidence to suggest that using existing risk prediction tools effectively reduces the incidence of PIs. Further research is needed on their clinical effectiveness, but only once promising prediction tools have been developed and appropriately validated.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: PLOS Medicine, 22 (2), e1004518.
This publication has 81 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluating medical tests: introducing the Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Diagnostic Test AccuracyCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2023
- Nutrition strategies for pressure injury management: Implementing the 2019 International Clinical Practice GuidelineNutrition in Clinical Practice, 2021
- Predictive validity of the braden scale for pressure injury risk assessment in adults: A systematic review and meta‐analysisNursing Open, 2021
- Risk assessment tools for the prevention of pressure ulcersCochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2019
- Preferred Reporting Items for a Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Diagnostic Test Accuracy StudiesJAMA, 2018
- Predicting pressure ulcer risk with the modified Braden, Braden, and Norton scales in acute care hospitals in Mainland ChinaApplied Nursing Research, 2005
- Properties of the summary receiver operating characteristic (SROC) curve for diagnostic test dataStatistics in Medicine, 2002
- Combining independent studies of a diagnostic test into a summary roc curve: Data‐analytic approaches and some additional considerationsStatistics in Medicine, 1993
- Trial of a pressure area risk calculator for intensive therapy patientsIntensive Care Nursing, 1991
- A Conceptual Schema for the Study of the Etiology of Pressure SoresRehabilitation Nursing Journal, 1987