Reflexive Museology: Lost and Found
Author:
- Shelley Ruth ButlerSBShelley Ruth Butler
- 24 April 2015
- book chapter
- Published by Wiley
- p. 159-182
Abstract
This chapter explores the contemporary status of critical reflexive museology in theory and practice. I begin by discussing the canonization ofInto the Heart of Africa, a landmark case of flawed reflexive museology, and then trace what has happened to reflexive museology since the mid‐1990s. I argue that a specific notion of postmodern reflexive museology has receded from contemporary museological debates. However, two decades of practical experimentation with reflexivity, alongside a global proliferation of museums and an increasingly heterogeneous public sphere, has meant that many tactics associated with reflexivity – such as self‐critique and multivocality – are now quite mainstream, and are incorporated into the broader paradigm shift of new museology. I argue that, while reflexivity's association with postmodernism is complicated, the end result is exhibitions that are less monolithic and more visitor‐centered. At this juncture, it is necessary to evaluate on a case‐by‐case basis, not only curators’ and educators’ effectiveness at translating reflexivity into practice, but also the impact and afterlife of their interventions.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- The future of the other2010
- Culture and Constraints: Further Thoughts on Ethnography and ExhibitingInternational Journal of Heritage Studies, 2006
- Re-placing Objects: Historical Practices for the Second Museum AgeCanadian Historical Review, 2005
- The Politics of Exhibiting Culture: Legacies and PossibilitiesMuseum Anthropology, 2000
- Scrap Irony: An Exhibit Review EssayCity & Society, 1998
- Breaking the Mould?: Exhibiting Khoisan in Southern African MuseumsAnthropology Today, 1996
- Postmodernism and Cultural Politics in a Multicultural Nation: Contests over Truth in the Into the Heart of Africa ControversyPublic Culture, 1995
- Ambiguous Messages and Ironic Twists: Into the Heart of Africa and The Other MuseumMuseum Anthropology, 1991
- Exhibiting Cultures: "Into the Heart of Africa"Visual Anthropology Review, 1991
- The Museum, a Temple or the Forum1Curator: The Museum Journal, 1971