The Unsustainable Proximity Paradox in Medium-Sized Cities: A Qualitative Study on User Perceptions of Mobility Policies
Open Access
Abstract
Medium-sized cities face unique challenges in fostering sustainable mobility due to their socio-spatial characteristics, including recent decentralized services and urban sprawl. This study examines user-centric factors influencing mobility behaviors in Caceres, Spain, through qualitative focus group analysis with 18 participants across two age groups. By employing a co-occurrence methodology, this research identifies key relationships within four thematic areas: public transport, active mobility, innovation, and urban planning. The findings reveal persistent car dependency despite sustainable policies, driven by the following: (1) inadequate public transport coordination between urban and regional areas, poor information availability, and lack of service synchronization; (2) perceived safety concerns, insufficient infrastructure for cycling, and ineffective pedestrianization strategies; (3) limited adoption of technological solutions due to cultural barriers, preference for informal arrangements, and usability issues with transport apps; and (4) mismatches between urban form and service distribution, proximity perception, and consumer preferences reinforcing car dependency. This study underscores the need for integrated transport systems, mixed land-use planning, and improved accessibility measures to achieve equitable and sustainable mobility transitions. The conclusion includes a series of policy recommendations.Keywords
Funding Information
- Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación (PID2019-104273RB-100)
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- X-minute cities as a growing notion of sustainable urbanism: A literature reviewCities, 2025
- Pathways to 15-Minute City adoption: Can our understanding of climate policies' acceptability explain the backlash towards x-minute city programs?Cities, 2024
- Can we all coexist? An empirical analysis of drivers' and pedestrians' behavior in four different shared space road environmentsCities, 2023
- Street pedestrianization in urban districts: Economic impacts in Spanish citiesCities, 2022
- Smart cities and behavioural change: (Un)sustainable mobilities in the neo-liberal cityGeoforum, 2021
- Investigating conflict behaviours and characteristics in shared space for pedestrians, conventional bicycles and e-bikesAccident Analysis & Prevention, 2021
- Urban sustainability assessment: An overview and bibliometric analysisEcological Indicators, 2021
- Depopulation of Toledo's historical centre in Spain? Challenge for local politics in world heritage citiesCities, 2020
- When age means safety: Data to assess trends and differences on rule knowledge, risk perception, aberrant and positive road behaviors, and traffic crashes of cyclistsData in Brief, 2019
- The changes of activity-travel participation across gender, life-cycle, and generations in Sweden over 30 yearsTransportation, 2018