Abstract
Marcantonio (Oct. 12 issue)1 lists urinary tract infection as a contributing factor to delirium in older patients and recommends evaluating and treating such patients for urinary tract infection. However, underlying cognitive and functional deficits predispose elderly patients to both delirium and asymptomatic bacteriuria, creating an association even without causation.2 The attribution of delirium to coincidentally discovered (and probably causally unrelated) bacteriuria leads to considerable use of antibiotic agents, with uncertain benefit and possible harms. This clinical scenario represents a contentious evidence-free zone. Infectious disease specialists regard this entity as asymptomatic bacteriuria, for which high-quality evidence supports nontreatment.2,3 By contrast, other providers regard it as urinary tract infection, to be managed as suggested by Marcantonio. The use of a descriptor that is less loaded than asymptomatic bacteriuria or urinary tract infection could be helpful; “bacteriuria or pyuria of clinically undetermined significance” has been proposed.4 Pending the results of randomized, clinical trials showing that patients who have delirium and bacteriuria or pyuria of clinically undetermined significance are, on balance, helped more than harmed by antimicrobial therapy, recommendations to test and treat them routinely for putative urinary tract infection should be tempered by the lack of supporting evidence and the clear risk of harms.