Obstetricians' agreement on fetal prognosis after ultrasound diagnosis of fetal anomalies
Authors:
- Hilmar H. BijmaHBHilmar H. Bijma
- Hajo I. J. WildschutHWHajo I. J. Wildschut
- Agnes van der HeideAHAgnes van der Heide
- Paul J. van der MaasPMPaul J. van der Maas
- Juriy W. WladimiroffJWJuriy W. Wladimiroff
- 6 September 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Prenatal Diagnosis
- Vol. 24 (9) , 713-718
Abstract
Introduction: After ultrasound diagnosis of a severe fetal anomaly is made, difficult decisions may arise regarding obstetric management. Guidelines have been developed to support obstetricians in decision‐making. However, it is unknown to what extent in the clinical situation, guidelines are actually supportive.Objectives: We aimed at: (1) determining whether obstetricians in the presence of a fetal anomaly are able to classify fetal prognosis according to guidelines; (2) establishing inter‐ and intra‐observer agreement regarding fetal prognosis.Methods: We used three categories of fetal prognosis: category 1: the infant has no chance of survival and the abnormalities cannot be treated (1.1); or the infant has a chance of extra‐uterine survival but post‐natal use of life‐prolonging medical treatment is considered futile (1.2); category 2: the infant has a chance of extra‐uterine survival and post‐natal use of life‐prolonging medical treatment, if necessary, is considered beneficial. Five senior obstetricians categorized 100 case descriptions of severe fetal abnormalities, which were classified again after five months.Results: Four obstetricians were able to classify 98% or more of cases. In 67% of cases, four or all obstetricians agreed on fetal prognosis. The overall kappa coefficient was 0.48 (moderate agreement). The differences between obstetricians represented systematic differences in opinions on how to classify cases. Intra‐observer agreement was 82 to 97%.Conclusion: Obstetricians were usually able to classify fetal prognosis according to guidelines, but in a substantial number of cases, there was a disagreement reflecting systematic differences between obstetricians. Copyright © 2004 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Trends in elective terminations of pregnancy between 1989 and 2000 in a French county (the Isère)Prenatal Diagnosis, 2003
- Euthanasia and other end-of-life decisions in the Netherlands in 1990, 1995, and 2001The Lancet, 2003
- Ethical Issues in the Management of Pregnancies Complicated by Fetal AnomaliesObstetrical & Gynecological Survey, 2003
- Conditions and consequences of medical futility—from a literature review to a clinical modelJournal of Medical Ethics, 2002
- Perinatal Management of Fetal Cardiac Anomalies in a Specialized Obstetric-Pediatrics CenterAmerican Journal of Perinatology, 2001
- Evaluation of prenatal diagnosis of associated congenital heart diseases by fetal ultrasonographic examination in EuropePrenatal Diagnosis, 2001
- Clinical guidelines: Potential benefits, limitations, and harms of clinical guidelinesBMJ, 1999
- A Dutch report on the ethics of neonatal care.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1995
- Judicial warning on very late abortionsThe Lancet, 1990
- Prenatal diagnosis of congenital anomalies requiring surgical correctionThe American Journal of Surgery, 1985