A Comparative Study of Control Methods for X3D Quadrotor Feedback Trajectory Control
Open Access
- 15 September 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Applied Sciences
- Vol. 12 (18) , 9254
Abstract
Unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), particularly quadrotor, have seen steady growth in use over the last several decades. The quadrotor is an under-actuated nonlinear system with few actuators in comparison to the degree of freedom (DOF); hence, stabilizing its attitude and positions is a significant challenge. Furthermore, the inclusion of nonlinear dynamic factors and uncertainties makes controlling its maneuverability more challenging. The purpose of this research is to design, implement, and evaluate the effectiveness of linear and nonlinear control methods for controlling an X3D quadrotor’s intended translation position and rotation angles while hovering. The dynamics of the X3D quadrotor model were implemented in Simulink. Two linear controllers, linear quadratic regulator (LQR) and proportional integral derivate (PID), and two nonlinear controllers, fuzzy controller (FC) and model reference adaptive PID Controller (MRAPC) employing the MIT rule, were devised and implemented for the response analysis. In the MATLAB Simulink Environment, the transient performance of nonlinear and linear controllers for an X3D quadrotor is examined in terms of settling time, rising time, peak time, delay time, and overshoot. Simulation results suggest that the LQR control approach is better because of its robustness and comparatively superior performance characteristics to other controllers, particularly nonlinear controllers, listed at the same operating point, as overshoot is 0.0% and other factors are minimal for the x3D quadrotor. In addition, the LQR controller is intuitive and simple to implement. In this research, all control approaches were verified to provide adequate feedback for quadrotor stability.Keywords
Funding Information
- Future University Researchers (FUESP-2020/48)
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Fuzzy Controller Applied to a Remote Energy Harvesting Emulation PlatformSensors, 2020
- Control Methods Comparison for the Real Quadrotor on an Innovative Test StandApplied Sciences, 2020
- Position & Attitude Control of an Aerial Robot (Quadrotor) With Intelligent PID and State feedback LQR Controller: A Comparative Approach2019
- Feedback Linearization LQR Control for Quadcopter Position Tracking2018
- Easy Tracking of UAV Using PID ControllerPeriodica Polytechnica Transportation Engineering, 2018
- PID and LQR trajectory tracking control for an unmanned quadrotor helicopter: Experimental studies2016
- Zero dynamics stabilisation and adaptive trajectory tracking for WIP vehicles through feedback linearisation and LQR techniqueInternational Journal of Control, 2016
- Real time fuzzy controller for quadrotor stability control2014
- An integral predictive/nonlinear control structure for a quadrotor helicopterAutomatica, 2010
- PID control system analysis, design, and technologyIEEE Transactions on Control Systems Technology, 2005