Featuring 10 phenological estimators using simulated data
Open Access
- 4 May 2010
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 1 (2) , 140-150
Abstract
Summary: 1. Studies reporting phenological changes in response to climate change are numerous and concern all groups of living organisms. Phenological changes could cause mismatching in food chains, thus inducing important perturbations in ecosystem functioning. Nevertheless, the relevancy of the conclusions drawn from phenological studies strongly depends on the estimation accuracy of such phenological changes. Many different estimators exist and some have already raised major criticism, although they continue to be used. Therefore, there is a crucial need for an extensive study documenting the behaviour of phenological estimators. 2. Here, we compare the estimation efficiency of 10 phenological estimators: different first appearance dates, mean dates, different percentile dates and a smoothing method based on spline functions using simulated phenological data. Root mean‐squared errors and bias of the phenological estimations are calculated in relation to different parameters of the simulated phenological data. 3. Results show that first appearance dates behave as a very inaccurate and biased estimator regarding any phenological data set. Mean dates and estimates calculated using the smoothing method provided in general the most accurate estimates of phenological shifts. They were also the most robust to variation in sample sizes and to imperfect detectability. 4. Our results allow us to warn against the use of first appearance dates in future phenological studies and to recommend using mean dates or smoothing techniques to estimate phenological change of entire distributions. We also provide advice concerning phenological monitoring effort. These recommendations should most importantly apply to studies aiming at comparing phenological variation among sites or among species.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Climate change effects on migration phenology may mismatch brood parasitic cuckoos and their hostsBiology Letters, 2009
- Response of birds to climatic variability; evidence from the western fringe of EuropeInternational Journal of Biometeorology, 2009
- Something for the weekend? Examining the bias in avian phenological recordingInternational Journal of Biometeorology, 2008
- Bias in phenology assessments based on first appearance data of butterfliesOecologia, 2008
- Characterizing bird migration phenology using data from standardized monitoring at bird observatoriesClimate Research, 2007
- Climate and the complexity of migratory phenology: sexes, migratory distance, and arrival distributionsInternational Journal of Biometeorology, 2007
- The use of Bayesian analysis to detect recent changes in phenological events throughout the yearAgricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2006
- Effects of climatic change on the phenology of butterflies in the northwest Mediterranean BasinGlobal Change Biology, 2003
- Ecological responses to recent climate changeNature, 2002
- A new look at the statistical model identificationIEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 1974