Toward the validation of a National Risk Assessment against historical observations using a Bayesian approach: application to the Swiss case
Authors:
- 7 May 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Risk Research
- Vol. 22 (11) , 1323-1342
Abstract
National Risk Assessment (NRA) studies have recently received increased interest from governments, authorities and other involved stakeholders, e.g. civil protection agencies, emergency planners, etc. The NRA approach combines risk assessment methods and decision-making processes in a structured manner to support the prioritization and management of national hazards and threats. A NRA commonly builds upon an intensive information processing and judgmental exercise, therefore, in a qualitative or semi-quantitative way, requiring the cooperation of experts from various fields. The validation of a NRA is of great importance to ensure that the analysis of national hazard scenarios results in the implementation of adequate preparedness strategies and contingency planning. In this study, a first step toward a comprehensive framework for NRA validation is presented. The method is developed to evaluate the accuracy and consistency of establishing risk indicator values by expert elicitation by comparing it against historical experience. The proposed method is based on Bayesian analysis, and is tested in three hazard scenario case studies for the Swiss NRA. The results for the chosen Swiss NRA cases show that expert estimates and quantitative assessment of historical experience are overall in good agreement. However, scenario-specific assumptions and boundary conditions defined by the experts are not in all cases supported by evaluation of historical experience. Finally, the main drawback of the proposed approach is that it can only be applied to hazard scenarios with sufficient historical observations, while it has the advantage to be generic and thus applicable to other risk assessment contexts outside of NRA.Keywords
Funding Information
- Swiss Federal Office for Civil Protection
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- From the EditorsRisk Analysis, 2013
- What Can We Learn from the Evaluation of the Dutch National Risk Assessment?Risk Analysis, 2013
- What Can National Risk Assessors Learn from Decision Theorists and Psychologists?Risk Analysis, 2013
- Bayesian modeling to unmask and predict influenza A/H1N1pdm dynamics in LondonProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2011
- On the Complex Definition of Risk: A Systems‐Based ApproachRisk Analysis, 2009
- Probabilistic Sensitivity Analysis: Be a BayesianValue in Health, 2009
- What's Wrong with Risk Matrices?Risk Analysis, 2008
- An Application of Extreme Value Theory for Measuring Financial RiskComputational Economics, 2006
- Bayesian MCMC flood frequency analysis with historical informationJournal of Hydrology, 2005
- Assessing the Quality of Earthquake Catalogues: Estimating the Magnitude of Completeness and Its UncertaintyBulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 2005