Answering for yourself versus others: Direct versus indirect estimates of charitable donations
- 30 December 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Psychology & Marketing
- Vol. 38 (3) , 397-415
Abstract
When researchers ask about behavior in ethical contexts such as charitable giving, they sometimes use indirect questions (e.g., “what would another student donate?”), to allow people to project their actual desires onto the other without social desirability concerns. Despite their prevalence, there is a surfeit of research on whether indirect measures reflect actual behavior better than direct questions (e.g., “how much would you donate”). We addressed this study question, focusing on sensitivity accuracy, which is whether the measure moves up or down as actual behavior does. To measure sensitivity, we elicited direct, indirect, and actual monetary donations from each respondent. Across four studies, and many controls and manipulations, direct measures were significantly more sensitive than indirect measures. Our findings argue for caution in the use of indirect measures of prosocial behavior and also appear to rule out projection as the only/primary driver of indirect responses. Happily, though, these results provide a potential bright spot for researchers: with some minor guidelines and adjustments, direct measures can be, we argue, profitably used to estimate actual behavior in ethical domains.Keywords
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- More for the Many: The Influence of Entitativity on Charitable GivingJournal of Consumer Research, 2013
- Considering the Situation: Why People are Better Social Psychologists than Self-psychologistsSelf and Identity, 2013
- Why Don’t Employers Hire and Retain Workers with Disabilities?Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, 2011
- The Impact of Relative Position and Relational Closeness on the Reporting of Unethical ActsJournal of Business Ethics, 2005
- Relationship Commitment and Ethical Consumer Behavior in a Retail Setting: The Case of Receiving Too Much Change at the CheckoutJournal of Business Ethics, 2005
- Inside the Mind Reader's Tool Kit: Projection and Stereotyping in Mental State Inference.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2004
- Overconfidence: It Depends on How, What, and Whom You AskOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1999
- A new look at defensive projection: Thought suppression, accessibility, and biased person perception.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1997
- Children's emotional attributions to self versus other: An exploration of an assumption underlying projective techniques.Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1982
- Dimensions of projection.Psychological Bulletin, 1968