Comparative Usability Testing of Conventional and Single Incision Laparoscopic Surgery Devices
Authors:
- Bernadette McCroryBMBernadette McCrory
- Emily E. MillerEMEmily E. Miller
- 15 November 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Factors: The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society
- Vol. 55 (3) , 619-631
Abstract
The objective was to perform competitive usability testing to assess the user experience of conventional laparoscopic and laparoendoscopic single-site surgery (LESS) devices. Recent advancements in single-incision instrumentation have created more interest in and usage of LESS. However, neither LESS nor its novel multichannel access devices have been thoroughly studied. Using a simulation test bed and standardized laparoscopic surgery task, the user experience of three commercially available LESS devices was compared to conventional laparoscopic ports based on time on task, errors, task success, and perceived ease of use. There were no significant differences between devices for time on task, errors, or task success (p > .05). For all devices, there were significantly more recoverable than unrecoverable errors, and errors occurred more frequently during the second phase of the task when the dominant hand was more active (p < .0001). Conventional laparoscopy was rated as easier to use than were the LESS devices (p < .01). Device performance of a basic laparoscopic task was similar in both conventional laparoscopy and LESS. Each of the LESS devices facilitated efficient and accurate aiming and grasping movements compared to conventional laparoscopy. Further investigation of human factors and ergonomics of LESS is needed to further develop, evaluate, and refine single-site surgery technologies to create a user experience equivalent to conventional laparoscopy. Competitive usability testing of medical devices yields objective performance data that can be used to inform purchase decisions and future device design improvements.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Performance curve of basic skills in single-incision laparoscopy versus conventional laparoscopy: Is it really more difficult for the novice?Surgical Endoscopy, 2011
- Blood product positive patient identification: comparative simulation‐based usability test of two commercial productsTransfusion, 2011
- Laparoendoscopic single-site (LESS) surgery versus conventional laparoscopic surgery: comparison of surgical port performance in a surgical simulator with novicesSurgical Endoscopy, 2010
- Human factors in patient safety as an innovationApplied Ergonomics, 2010
- Laparo-Endoscopic Single Site (LESS) versus Standard Laparoscopic Left Donor Nephrectomy: Matched-pair ComparisonEuropean Urology, 2010
- Appendicectomy and Cholecystectomy Using Single-Incision Laparoscopic Surgery (SILS): The First UK ExperienceSurgical Innovation, 2009
- Surgeon Evaluation of Suture and Endo-Mechanical ProductsJournal of Surgical Research, 2007
- Assessment of medical devices: How to conduct comparative technology evaluations of product performanceInternational Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care, 2007
- Comparison of laparoscopic performance in vivo with performance measured in a laparoscopic simulatorSurgical Endoscopy, 1999
- Development of a Model for Training and Evaluation of Laparoscopic Skills 11This work was supported by an educational grant from United States Surgical Corporation (Auto Suture Canada).The American Journal of Surgery, 1998