At this historical moment, the Earth has no Other. Inspired by an epistemology proposed by Denis Cosgrove, this chapter reviews the main compelling reasons for extrapolating certain island qualities onto a planetary scale. After all, a particular trope has accompanied islands in the Western imaginary: as ideal locations for a perfect society, somewhat insulated from danger; as places of sanctuary and sacrality; as spaces that nurture and protect unique and fragile ecosystems; and as posterchildren of the Anthropocene, by serving as geographies of hope or despair. Such ideas are being readily applied to Planet Earth as a special island in space. The chapter reviews the changing conceptualisation of ‘Earth as Island’ from the vantage points of cartography and exobiology. The chapter thus engages with the largest single material object that can currently qualify as ‘home’.