Comparing dynamical, stochastic and combined downscaling approaches – lessons from a case study in the Mediterranean region

Authors:
  • NGN. Guyennon
    N. Guyennon
  • ERE. Romano
    E. Romano
  • IPI. Portoghese
    I. Portoghese
  • FSF. Salerno
    F. Salerno
  • SCS. Calmanti
    S. Calmanti
  • APA. B. Petrangeli
    A. B. Petrangeli
  • GTG. Tartari
    G. Tartari
  • DCD. Copetti
    D. Copetti

Abstract
Various downscaling techniques have been developed to bridge the scale gap between global climate models (GCMs) and finer scales required to assess hydrological impacts of climate change. Such techniques may be grouped into two downscaling approaches: the deterministic dynamical downscaling (DD) and the stochastic statistical downscaling (SD). Although SD has been traditionally seen as an alternative to DD, recent works on statistical downscaling have aimed to combine the benefits of these two approaches. The overall objective of this study is to examine the relative benefits of each downscaling approach and their combination in making the GCM scenarios suitable for basin scale hydrological applications. The case study presented here focuses on the Apulia region (South East of Italy, surface area about 20 000 km2), characterized by a typical Mediterranean climate; the monthly cumulated precipitation and monthly mean of daily minimum and maximum temperature distribution were examined for the period 1953–2000. The fifth-generation ECHAM model from the Max-Planck-Institute for Meteorology was adopted as GCM. The DD was carried out with the Protheus system (ENEA), while the SD was performed through a monthly quantile-quantile transform. The SD resulted efficient in reducing the mean bias in the spatial distribution at both annual and seasonal scales, but it was not able to correct the miss-modeled non-stationary components of the GCM dynamics. The DD provided a partial correction by enhancing the trend spatial heterogeneity and time evolution predicted by the GCM, although the comparison with observations resulted still underperforming. The best results were obtained through the combination of both DD and SD approaches.
All Related Versions

This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit: