The implementation of AI is a national priority in the UAE, however, empirical studies on its application at the school level, especially in newly developed regions of education such as Ras Al Khaimah’s (RAK) emirate, are in short supply. This paper examined the implementation of AI in RAK’s private schools and its implications for educational policy, ethical, and professional practice. A qualitative exploratory case study was used, where semi-structured interviews with 18 educators, representing schools adopting American and international baccalaureate curricula were held online. Interview data was analyzed using thematic analysis framework The findings showed that teachers and leaders in RAK’s private schools consider AI as a helpful aid that foster personalization, differentiation, and teaching efficiency and does not replace or negate teachers’ social and critical role in the learning process. In addition, issues of digital justice, ethical use, and inconsistent teacher preparedness revealed the significance of developing equitable policies fair distribution of material and human resources to support AI adoption. Recommendations for policymakers and school leaders to match AI innovation with classroom realities for more responsible integration of AI in education are offered.