Achieving clinically optimal balance between accuracy and simplicity of a formula for manual use: Development of a simple formula for estimating liver graft weight with donor anthropometrics
Open Access
- 20 January 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 18 (1) , e0280569
Abstract
In developing a formula for manual use in clinical settings, simplicity is as important as accuracy. Whole-liver (WL) mass is often estimated using demographic and anthropometric information to calculate the standard liver volume or recommended graft volume in liver transplantation. Multiple formulas for estimating WL mass have been reported, including those with multiple independent variables. However, it is unknown whether multivariable models lead to clinically meaningful improvements in accuracy over univariable models. Our goal was to quantitatively define clinically meaningful improvements in accuracy, which justifies an additional independent variable, and to identify an estimation formula for WL graft weight that best balances accuracy and simplicity given the criterion. From the Japanese Liver Transplantation Society registry, which contains data on all liver transplant cases in Japan, 129 WL donor-graft pairs were extracted. Among the candidate models, those with the smallest cross-validation (CV) root-mean-square error (RMSE) were selected, penalizing model complexity by requiring more complex models to yield a ≥5% decrease in CV RMSE. The winning model by voting with random subsets was fitted to the entire dataset to obtain the final formula. External validity was assessed using CV. A simple univariable linear regression formula using body weight (BW) was obtained as follows: WL graft weight [g] = 14.8 × BW [kg] + 439.2. The CV RMSE (g) and coefficient of determination (R2) were 195.2 and 0.548, respectively. In summary, in the development of a simple formula for manually estimating WL weight using demographic and anthropometric variables, a clinically acceptable trade-off between accuracy and simplicity was quantitatively defined, and the best model was selected using this criterion. A univariable linear model using BW achieved a clinically optimal balance between simplicity and accuracy, while one using body surface area performed similarly.Keywords
Funding Information
- Japan Foundation (19K09111)
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Estimation of body surface area in various childhood ages – validation of the Mosteller formulaActa Paediatrica, 2012
- Coefficient factor for graft weight estimation from preoperative computed tomography volumetry in living donor liver transplantationLiver Transplantation, 2010
- Standard Formula for Liver Volume in Middle Eastern Arabic AdultsTransplantation Proceedings, 2010
- Estimation of Standard Liver Volume in Chinese Adult Living DonorsTransplantation Proceedings, 2009
- Estimation of Standard Liver Volume for Japanese AdultsTransplantation Proceedings, 2008
- Estimation of standard liver volume in Japanese living liver donorsJournal of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, 2006
- “All‐in‐one” imaging protocols for the evaluation of potential living liver donors: Comparison of magnetic resonance imaging and multidetector computed tomographyLiver Transplantation, 2005
- Estimation of standard liver volume for liver transplantation in the Korean populationLiver Transplantation, 2004
- Estimation of liver size for liver transplantation: The impact of age and genderLiver Transplantation, 2004
- Standard liver volume in the caucasian populationLiver Transplantation and Surgery, 1999