JUE Insight: The Effect of Centralized School Assignment Systems on Between-School Segregation: Evidence from the 300 Largest School Districts in the United States
This study examines how the adoption of centralized school assignment systems affects between-school racial and ethnic segregation in the largest U.S. public school districts. Using an original nationwide panel dataset and a staggered difference-in-differences design, we estimate dynamic and average changes in district composition, intergroup exposure, and the evenness of student distributions across schools. Event-study estimates show that the main compositional and exposure changes generally emerge two to three years after adoption rather than as an immediate level shift. Adoption is associated on average with a 2.0 percentage point increase in the White share of district enrollment and modest, asymmetric changes in exposure: Black-White exposure increases by 1.6 percentage points and student of color-White exposure by 1.8 points, while White students’ exposure to Black, Asian, and students of color declines. These patterns can coexist because exposure is group-specific and depends on both group size and the schools attended by each group. We find no statistically significant effect on dissimilarity at any point in the event window. The results therefore indicate that, on average, moving to these types of centralized assignment systems produced gradual but modest changes in composition and peer exposure without materially altering the evenness of racial and ethnic sorting across schools.