Reviewing the reviews: the Global Compacts' added value in access to asylum procedures and immigration detention
Authors:
Open Access
- 22 November 2023
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Human Dynamics
- Vol. 5, 1264942
Abstract
The Global Compact for Migration and the Global Compact on Refugees are based on binding international law instruments whose provisions they complement with “best practice” standards related to the treatment of refugees and other migrants. Although the Compacts are non-binding, they provide for review mechanisms to promote compliance with Compact standards. Such oversight is important to achieve progress in implementing the Compacts' commitments. Yet, the current top-down and State-led review process does not offer an efficient platform for identifying cases of non-adherence to Compact standards. This article uses a case study approach to highlight instances of non-compliance with Compact standards in Canada, South Africa, and the European Union. We use a functionalist method of comparison to analyze State practice in these three regions in relation to (i) use of immigration detention and (ii) access to the asylum procedure, with access to healthcare as a cross-cutting issue. The article discusses how the Compacts' review mechanisms could be improved and their added value in terms of their impact on domestic migration policies. It argues that both Compact review and implementation can be improved through increased civil society participation.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- EU Immigration and Asylum Law (Text and Commentary): Second Revised Edition2015
- The securitization of asylum and human rights in Canada and the European Union2013
- Shifting Borders and the Boundaries of Rights: Examining the Safe Third Country Agreement between Canada and the United StatesInternational Journal of Refugee Law, 2013
- We Need to Cut Off the Head of the King: Past, Present, and Future Approaches to International Soft LawLeiden Journal of International Law, 2012
- Overcoming the Mere Heuristic Aspirations of (Functional) Comparative Legal Research? An Exploration into the Possibilities and Limits of Behavioral EconomicsGlobal Jurist, 2009
- Mobilizing for Human Rights2009
- Global Administrative Law Dimensions of International Organizations LawInternational Organizations Law Review, 2009
- Incomplete Internalization and Compliance with Human Rights LawEuropean Journal of International Law, 2008
- The Exercise of International Public Authority through National Policy Assessment: The OECD's PISA Policy as a Paradigm for a New International Standard InstrumentInternational Organizations Law Review, 2008
- Introduction: Global Governance and Global Administrative Law in the International Legal OrderEuropean Journal of International Law, 2006