Healing Pressure Ulcers with Collagen or Hydrocolloid: A Randomized, Controlled Trial
Authors:
- James F. GraumlichJGJames F. Graumlich
- Linda S. BloughLBLinda S. Blough
- L. William ScheibelLSL. William Scheibel
- 31 January 2003
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the American Geriatrics Society
- Vol. 51 (2) , 147-154
Abstract
OBJECTIVES :To compare the effects of topical collagen and hydrocolloid on pressure ulcer healing. DESIGN: Randomized (allocation concealed), single‐blind (outcome assessors), controlled trial with 8‐week follow‐up. SETTING :Eleven nursing homes in central Illinois. PARTICIPANTS :Sixty‐five patient‐residents with Stage II or III pressure ulcers: median age 83.1, median Braden score 12, 63% female, 80% Stage II ulcers, and 20% Stage III ulcers. Exclusion criteria included cellulitis and osteomyelitis. INTERVENTION: Thirty‐five patients were allocated to topical collagen daily, 30 to topical hydrocolloid twice weekly. MEASUREMENTS: The primary outcome was complete healing within 8 weeks. Secondary outcomes were time to heal, ulcer area healed per day, linear healing of wound edge, and cost of therapy. RESULTS: Analysis by intention to treat revealed similar complete ulcer healing within 8 weeks in collagen (51%) and hydrocolloid (50%) recipients (difference 1%, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 26–29%). Mean healing time was similar: collagen healed in 5 weeks (95% CI = 4–6), hydrocolloid healed in 6 weeks (95% CI = 5–7). Mean area healed per day was 6 mm 2 /d in both treatment groups. Mean linear healing of the wound edge was 3 mm in both groups. In multivariate analysis, baseline ulcer depth was the only independent predictor of complete ulcer healing within 8 weeks (odds ratio = 0.56, 95% CI = 0.38–0.81). Cost analysis favored hydrocolloid. CONCLUSIONS: There were no significant differences in healing outcome between collagen and hydrocolloid. Collagen was more expensive and offered no major benefits to patients otherwise eligible for hydrocolloid treatment. J Am Geriatr Soc 51:147–154, 2003.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Quality Indicators for Prevention and Management of Pressure Ulcers in Vulnerable EldersAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2001
- Evaluation of a Risk‐Adjustment Model for Pressure Ulcer Development Using the Minimum Data SetJournal of the American Geriatrics Society, 2001
- Topically Applied Bovine Collagen in the Treatment of Ulcerative Necrobiosis Lipoidica DiabeticorumArchives of Dermatology, 1997
- Effect of Pressure Ulcers on the Survival of Long-Term Care ResidentsThe Journals of Gerontology, Series A: Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences, 1997
- A Comparison of Xeroform and SkinTemp Dressings in the Healing of Skin Graft Donor SitesJournal of Burn Care & Rehabilitation, 1995
- Correlates of Pressure Sores in Nursing Homes: Evidence from the National Medical Expenditure Survey.Journal of Investigative Dermatology, 1994
- Pressure ulcers: Prevalence, etiology, and treatment modalitiesThe American Journal of Surgery, 1994
- A Prospective Study of Pressure Sore Risk among Institutionalized ElderlyJournal of the American Geriatrics Society, 1992
- Pressure Ulcers among the ElderlyNew England Journal of Medicine, 1989
- Clinical Trials1986