Estimating the prevalence of negative attitudes towards people with disability: a comparison of direct questioning, projective questioning and randomised response
- 1 January 2011
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Disability and Rehabilitation
- Vol. 33 (5) , 399-411
Abstract
Purpose. Despite being susceptible to social desirability bias, attitudes towards people with disabilities are traditionally assessed via self-report. We investigated two methods presumably providing more valid prevalence estimates of sensitive attitudes than direct questioning (DQ). Most people projective questioning (MPPQ) attempts to reduce bias by asking interviewees to estimate the number of other people holding a sensitive attribute, rather than confirming or denying the attribute for themselves. The randomised-response technique (RRT) tries to reduce bias by assuring confidentiality through a random scrambling of the respondent's answers. Method. We assessed negative attitudes towards people with physical and mental disability via MPPQ, RRT and DQ to compare the resulting estimates. Results. The MPPQ estimates exceeded the DQ estimates. Employing a cheating-detection extension of the RRT, we determined the proportion of respondents disregarding the RRT instructions and computed an upper bound for the prevalence of negative attitudes. MPPQ estimates exceeded this upper bound and were thus shown to overestimate the prevalence. Furthermore, we found more negative attitudes towards people with mental disabilities than those with physical disabilities in all three questioning conditions. Conclusions. We recommend employing the cheating-detection variant of the RRT to gain additional insight in future studies on attitudes towards people with disabilities.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sensitive questions in surveys.Psychological Bulletin, 2007
- Mental Health Professionals' Disability Competence: Measuring Self-Awareness, Perceived Knowledge, and Perceived Skills.Rehabilitation Psychology, 2004
- Effects of faking on self-deception and impression management scalesPersonality and Individual Differences, 2004
- Attitudes Toward People with Intellectual DisabilitiesJournal of Disability Policy Studies, 2004
- Disabled people's attitudes toward other impairment groups: a hierarchy of impairmentsDisability & Society, 2003
- Measurement of attitudes towards persons with disabilitiesDisability and Rehabilitation, 2000
- Direct and indirect methods to measure attitudes toward persons with disabilities, with an exegesis of the error-choice test method.Rehabilitation Psychology, 1995
- Money Incentives and Family Size: A Hypothetical-Question StudyPublic Opinion Quarterly, 1974
- Identification of Determinant Attributes: A Comparison of MethodsJournal of Marketing Research, 1971
- Do They Tell the Truth?Public Opinion Quarterly, 1944