Has a small-scale structure in turbulence been experimentally verified?

Authors:

Abstract
Various investigators have found considerable experimental evidence for small-scale flow structures in wall-bounded turbulent flow within the last 15 years. Experiments by Willmarth and Bogar in 1977 [Phys. Fluids 20, S9 (October, Part II, 1977)] provided the high point to date in efforts to measure small-scale phenomena associated with turbulence; the unexpected results of these investigations were ascribed to extremely small flow structures of a scale which previously had remained undetected. Since publication of the work of Willmarth and Bogar, neither verifications nor contradictory results have been published by other investigators. The present experimental studies seem to contradict the thesis of Willmarth and Bogar, making small-scale phenomena responsible for the unusual results of their experiments.