Screening Criteria and Methodology for Quality Check and PVT Selection for Reservoir Studies

Authors:

Abstract
In the literature, there isn't a unified criterion to establish a methodology for quality assessment of PVT analysis. Worldwide, engineers have proposed the use of well-known validation methodologies but these validation methodologies not necessarily encompasses the whole consistency of a PVT study or its representativeness of the reservoir fluids. It is well known that a PVT study might have a great consistency after it's validated but when it's used in a reservoir characterization it didn't reproduce the measured behavior of the fluid present in the reservoir. These types of inconsistencies are common and could cause very important errors in analysis such as: Original volume, reserves estimation, surface facilities planning and exploitation strategies. The impact on the results and decisions taken based on the information present in a PVT study can be crucial and therefore every PVT analysis should include a level of uncertainty index that could allow to know beforehand the cost of using such information. The versatility and complexity of most the experiments conducted during a PVT study makes the task of creating a unique methodology of quality quantification difficult. The present paper proposes a methodology for quality control and uncertainty assessment. This methodology considers each of the stages involved in the process of obtaining a PVT analysis: from the fluid sampling to the experiments results. According to previous work and field experience, the most important parameters or conditions were selected at each stage. These parameters are called Critical Points; each Critical Point has and associated impact level (high, medium and low.) and weight that reflects directly in the overall quality index of the PVT study. Critical points were subsequently grouped into 6 Control Categories: Sampling conditions, reservoir conditions, experiments control, measured properties control, fluid type validation and validation of experiment consistency. An ideal value of 10.0 was established for a report PVT that has excellent condition, very low uncertainty and meets all the conditions proposed in this paper. Additionally, a Quality Index (QI) and Validation Index (VI) were proposed as two indicative values of the level of uncertainty of any PVT study. Using a proposed Nomograph, engineers can evaluate and categorize the quality results from any PVT study. The results from applying this methodology to 50 PVT studies are presented and a Material Balance and numerical simulation study were carried out to exemplify the impact of using for the same reservoir, PVT from different level of quality. The goal of this work is to have a practical methodology that can give engineers a "Quality Index" of any PVT study. This quality index could be an indicative of the level of uncertainty and the degree of reliability of the PVT study before it's subsequently used in any reservoir or well analysis. This methodology could be used worldwide without limitations