Abstract
The law in England and Wales concerning the making of legally significant decisions by adults who are mentally incapable is confused and, in terms of its implicit attitudes towards people with mental illnesses and learning disabilities, it is lagging behind changes in social policy. There have been major changes in this area of law, in recent years, in several other developed countries. The Law Commission in England and Wales is undertaking a review of this area of law and has published three consultation papers. This article examines the premises and principles underpinning the Law Commission's papers. It argues that the Commission's proposals do not match the needs or the emergent service philosophies and should be fundamentally reconsidered.