A comparison of soil and environmental quality under organic and conventional farming systems in New Zealand
- 1 December 2000
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research
- Vol. 43 (4) , 443-466
Abstract
Organic farming in its various forms is seen by many as a sustainable alternative to conventional farming. This review considers and compares aspects of soil and environmental quality associated with organic and conventional farming systems under New Zealand conditions. The sustainability parameters considered include soil quality, nutrient dynamics, nutrient budgets, trace elements, and pesticides. The review used information from appropriate comparative studies conducted in New Zealand and overseas. However, because of the shortage of data on nutrient dynamics under organic systems in New Zealand, we also used a nutrient balance model (OVERSEER) and a nitrogen leaching estimation model to assess the comparative sustainability of typical model systems. Interpretation of the measured data coupled with the results of the modelling exercise suggests that organic farming carried out according to the Bio‐Gro New Zealand production standards can be sustainable if sufficient amounts of nutrient are returned to match removal and losses. Bio‐dynamic farming may be unsustainable because nutrients removed in farm produce are not adequately replaced. Soil organic matter content and biological activity is generally higher under both types of organic system than under conventional systems. Trace element availability and use may limit the sustainability of organic systems if no attempt is made to address natural deficiencies common in New Zealand soils. The reduced use of pesticides may be beneficial for the wider environment. The main conclusion is that a concerted research effort is urgently required to address various soil and environmental quality issues associated with the large‐scale adoption of organic farming practices in New Zealand.Keywords
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- Effect of soil pH on cadmium phytoavailability in some New Zealand soilsNew Zealand Journal of Crop and Horticultural Science, 1999
- Organic Farming and the Environment, with Particular Reference to Australia: A ReviewBiological Agriculture & Horticulture, 1998
- Survey of pesticides in New Zealand groundwaters, 1994New Zealand Journal of Marine and Freshwater Research, 1996
- Abundance and diversity of beneficial arthropods in conventional and “organic” carrot crops in New ZealandNew Zealand Journal of Crop and Horticultural Science, 1996
- Cadmium status of soils, plants, and grazing animals in New ZealandNew Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research, 1994
- Seaweed Extracts in Agriculture and Horticulture: a ReviewBiological Agriculture & Horticulture, 1992
- Effect of cobalt application on the cobalt status of pastures 1. Pastures with history of regular cobalt applicationNew Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research, 1990
- The Environmental Effects of Conventional and Organic/Biological Farming systems. II. Soil Ecology, Soil Fertility and Nutrient CyclesBiological Agriculture & Horticulture, 1988
- Model for calculating maintenance phosphate requirements for grazed pasturesNew Zealand Journal of Crop and Horticultural Science, 1982
- COBALT AND NICKEL IN SOILS AND PLANTSSoil Science, 1945