Understanding Policy Change as an Epistemological and Theoretical Problem
- 2 March 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice
- Vol. 11 (1) , 7-31
Abstract
Change is the fundamental focus of those who are interested in studying public policy. As a result of the multidimensional nature of policy dynamics, policy change is a very ambiguous area of academic study, and one full of pitfalls. All aspects of policy change have been dealt with, all the possible independent variables have been examined (ideas, interests, institutions, socio-economic structures, political institutions, internationalization, individual entrepreneurship, social culture and values, and so on), and a great many theoretical frameworks, combining diverse causal mechanisms, have been proposed. However, when choosing certain independent variables, or the specific design of the dependent variable, or a particular sequence of causal factors, policy scholars make a series of strong epistemological and theoretical choices which they are often not conscious of (as revealed by the fact that their frameworks and theories may be incoherent and characterized by evident shortcomings). In this paper, I am going to present the kind of analytical questions which need to be resolved from the epistemological and theoretical points of view, in order to grasp the essence of policy change and the potential consequences of the aforesaid choices. I shall then review the way in which the most important policy/change frameworks (Multiple Stream Approach, Punctuated Equilibrium Framework, Advocacy Coalition Framework, and Path Dependency Framework) have attempted to solve the epistemological and theoretical puzzle, the degree to which they are coherent, and the pros and cons of the solutions they adopt. Finally, I conclude by presenting a number of recommendations for further theoretical reflection and empirical investigation regarding the epistemological and theoretical coherence and effectiveness of theories of policy change.Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Punctuating Which Equilibrium? Understanding Thermostatic Policy Dynamics in Pacific Northwest ForestryAmerican Journal of Political Science, 2007
- The Grip of History and the Scope for Novelty: Some Results and Open Questions on Path Dependence in Economic Processes2006
- Chaos and Transformation Theories: A Theoretical Analysis with Implications for Organization Theory and Public ManagementPublic Organization Review, 2003
- Emergence: A Construct Amid a Thicket of Conceptual SnaresEmergence, 2000
- Multiple Levels of Analysis from a Longitudinal Perspective: Some Implications for Theory BuildingAcademy of Management Review, 1999
- Political science and the comparative study of policy change in higher education: theoretico-methodological notes from a policy perspectiveHigher Education, 1996
- Policy Paradigms, Social Learning, and the State: The Case of Economic Policymaking in BritainComparative Politics, 1993
- Revolutionary Change Theories: A Multilevel Exploration of the Punctuated Equilibrium ParadigmAcademy of Management Review, 1991
- Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policy: Lessons from the U.S. Foreign Policy ArenaJournal of Public Policy, 1989
- Punctuated equilibria: the tempo and mode of evolution reconsideredPaleobiology, 1977