Towards Understanding Autism Heterogeneity: Identifying Clinical Subgroups and Neuroanatomical Deviations
Preprint
Abstract
Autism Spectrum Disorder (‘autism’) is a neurodevelopmental condition characterized by substantial behavioural and neuroanatomical heterogeneity. This poses significant challenges to understanding its neurobiological mechanisms and developing effective interventions. Identifying phenotypically more homogeneous subgroups and shifting the focus from average group differences to individuals is a promising approach to addressing heterogeneity. In the present study, we aimed to parse clinical and neuroanatomical heterogeneity in autism by combining clustering of clinical features with normative modeling based on neuroanatomical measures (cortical thickness [CT] and subcortical volume) within the ABIDE datasets (N autism=861, N neurotypical=886, age-range 5-64). First, model-based clustering was applied to autistic symptoms as measured by the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule to identify clinical subgroups of autism. Next, we examined whether clinical subgrouping resulted in increased neurobiological homogeneity within the subgroups compared to the entire autism group by comparing their spatial overlap of neuroanatomical deviations. We further investigated whether the identified subgroups improved the accuracy of autism classification based on the neuroanatomical deviations using supervised machine learning with cross-validation. Results yielded two clinical subgroups primarily differing in restrictive and repetitive behaviours (RRB). Both subgroups showed increased homogeneity in localized deviations with the high-RRB subgroup showing increased volume deviations in cerebellum and the low-RRB subgroup showing decreased CT deviations predominantly in the postcentral gyrus and fusiform cortex. Nevertheless, substantial within-group heterogeneity remained highlighted by the failure of the classifier to distinguish between the subgroups. Identifying subgroups of autism has substantial clinical implications opening the potential for more tailored behavioural interventions and improving clinical outcomes. General Scientific Summary: Autism is characterized by pronounced behavioural and neurobiological heterogeneity. This study suggests that reducing this heterogeneity at the clinical level by employing subgrouping also results in more similar neuroanatomical profiles in the identified clinical subgroups. Although we could demonstrate that clinical subgrouping reduces neuroanatomical heterogeneity, simultaneously, there remained substantial heterogeneity potentially pointing towards multiple pathways resulting in high RRBs and neurobiological subgroups with similar clinical phenotypes.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Journal of Psychopathology and Clinical Science, 133 (8), 667.
This publication has 89 references indexed in Scilit:
- Gray matter volume alteration is associated with insistence on sameness and cognitive flexibility in autistic youthAutism Research, 2022
- A Data Driven Approach Reveals That Anomalous Motor System Connectivity is Associated With the Severity of Core Autism SymptomsAutism Research, 2021
- Understanding and Addressing Restricted and Repetitive Behaviors in Children with Autism2020
- Mapping the Heterogeneous Phenotype of Schizophrenia and Bipolar Disorder Using Normative ModelsJAMA Psychiatry, 2018
- Costs of Autism Spectrum Disorders in the United Kingdom and the United StatesJAMA Pediatrics, 2014
- Early Brain Overgrowth in Autism Associated With an Increase in Cortical Surface Area Before Age 2 YearsArchives of General Psychiatry, 2011
- Model-Based Clustering2011
- The Role of the Fusiform-Amygdala System in the Pathophysiology of AutismArchives of General Psychiatry, 2010
- Novel clustering of items from the Autism Diagnostic Interview‐Revised to define phenotypes within autism spectrum disordersAutism Research, 2009
- Amygdalar Volume and Behavioral Development in AutismArchives of General Psychiatry, 2006