Ethics in Transnational Forensic DNA Data Exchange in the EU: Constructing Boundaries and Managing Controversies
Open Access
- 22 January 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Science as Culture
- Vol. 27 (2) , 242-264
Abstract
Under EU Law, Member States are compelled to engage in reciprocal automated forensic DNA profile exchange for stepping up on cross-border cooperation, particularly in combating terrorism and cross-border crime. The ethical implications of this transnational DNA data exchange are paramount. Exploring what the concept of ethics means to forensic practitioners actively involved in transnational DNA data exchange allows discussing how ethics can be addressed as embedded in the sociality of science and in the way scientific work is legitimated. The narratives of forensic practitioners juxtapose the construction of fluid ethical boundary work between science and non-science with the dynamic management of controversies, both of which are seen as ways to lend legitimacy and objectivity to scientific work. Ethical boundary work involves diverse fluid forms: as a boundary between science/ethics, science/criminal justice system, and good and bad science. The management of controversies occurs in three interrelated ways. First, through a continuous process of reconstructing delegations of responsibility in dealing with uncertainty surrounding the reliability of DNA evidence. Second, threats to the protection of data are portrayed as being resolved by black-boxing privacy. Finally, controversies related to social accountability and transparency are negotiated through the lens of opening science to the public.Keywords
Funding Information
- FEDER from the Operational Programme Factors of Competitiveness – COMPETE – and Foundation for Science and Technology – FCT – (Portuguese Ministry of Education and Science (Grant IF/00829/ 2013)
- European Research Council (Consolidator grant agreement no. 648608)
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Science, truth, and forensic cultures: The exceptional legal status of DNA evidenceStudies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 2013
- Transnational Exchange of Forensic DNA: Viability, Legitimacy, and AcceptabilityEuropean Journal on Criminal Policy and Research, 2011
- SILENT WITNESS, ARTICULATE COLLECTIVE: DNA EVIDENCE AND THE INFERENCE OF VISIBLE TRAITSBioethics, 2008
- Sociology, ethics, and the priority of the particular: learning from a case study of genetic deliberationsThe British Journal of Sociology, 2007
- Forensic genetics and ethical, legal and social implications beyond the clinicNature Genetics, 2004
- The Drugs Don't WorkSocial Studies of Science, 2003
- Protocols, practices, and the reproduction of technique in molecular biology*The British Journal of Sociology, 2002
- Legal EngineeringSocial Studies of Science, 2002
- Compensatory ethics for the human genome projectScience as Culture, 1996
- Boundary-Work and the Demarcation of Science from Non-Science: Strains and Interests in Professional Ideologies of ScientistsAmerican Sociological Review, 1983