Deficit narratives as teacher foils: how vulnerability and emotional regimes shape teacher discourse
Open Access
- 3 August 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Instructional Science
- Vol. 53 (6) , 1871-1888
Abstract
Teachers’ collegial conversations can be important sites for teachers’ learning, but sometimes result in deficit narratives about students and families. Research seldom “gets inside” teachers’ collegial conversations to shed light on when and why deficit narratives arise. In this study, we investigate how deficit narratives are co-constructed, and what function they serve in teachers’ discourse. Specifically, we look at the relationship between teachers’ assignation of responsibility in relation to teacher vulnerability. Critical discourse analysis makes visible how teacher vulnerability and emotions precipitated deficit narratives. Across cases, we found that teachers offered deficit narratives in response to teacher vulnerability under emotional regimes that disallowed strong negative emotions. These deficit narratives served to shift the threat and return teachers’ emotions to acceptable levels under these emotional regimes. These findings have implications for design of teachers’ learning environments; in addition to addressing deficit ideas themselves, findings suggest the importance of attending to how emotional regimes structure teachers’ responses to vulnerability in teachers’ collegial talk.Keywords
Funding Information
- Directorate for STEM Education (1620920)
- National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship Program (DGE-1445197)
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- Designing to support equity-as-transformation perspectives for multilingual science learnersInstructional Science, 2024
- “Even when it was hard, you pushed us to improve”: Emotions and teacher learning in coaching conversationsTeaching and Teacher Education, 2022
- “As Tunisian I feel ashamed by this disgusting presenter”: Collective face threat and identity positioning on FacebookDiscourse, Context & Media, 2022
- Interactional production of deficit talk in a professional development for mathematics teachersJournal of Mathematics Teacher Education, 2021
- Teachers’ perceptions of emotional display rules in schools: A systematic reviewTeaching and Teacher Education, 2021
- Teacher noticing from a sociopolitical perspective: the FAIR framework for anti-deficit noticingZDM – Mathematics Education, 2021
- “Do I feel threatened? No… I’m learning!”—Affective and relational dynamics in science professional developmentScience Education, 2018
- Scientism and Education2007
- The Functions of Teacher Emotions: The Good, the Bad, and the UglyTeachers College Record: the Voice of Scholarship in Education, 2003
- Communities of Practice1998