Approaches to Confounder Selection in Observational Studies Investigating Associations Between Physical Activity and Health-Related Outcomes: A Review
Authors:
- Terry BoyleTBTerry Boyle
- Leonessa BoingLBLeonessa Boing
- Barbara JefferisBJBarbara Jefferis
- Shaea AlkahtaniSAShaea Alkahtani
- Derrick A BennettDBDerrick A Bennett
- Elli KontostoliEKElli Kontostoli
- Matthew MclaughlinMatthew Mclaughlin
- Aoko OluwayomiAOAoko Oluwayomi
- Kabir P. SadaranganiKSKabir P. Sadarangani
- Philip von RosenPRPhilip von Rosen
- Stephanie A. PrinceSPStephanie A. Prince
- Lin YangLin Yang
- 1 January 2026
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Human Kinetics in Journal of Physical Activity and Health
- Vol. -1 (aop) , 1-7
Abstract
Background : There are many different confounder selection approaches. It is considered best practice, and recommended by reporting guidelines, that the choice of confounders is described and justified. We aimed to describe practices in confounder selection in epidemiological studies using observational data to investigate the effect of physical activity-related exposures on health-related outcomes. Methods : A structured search strategy was used to identify studies estimating the effect of a physical activity-related exposure on a health-related outcome using individual-level observational data, published in 2021–2022. A total of 1353 articles were identified in the screening process, 300 of which were randomly selected for full-text screening and data extraction. Data extracted included the approach(es) used to select confounders and study characteristics. Results : Of the 300 selected articles, 279 were eligible. Most (61%) did not describe their approach to choosing confounders. Around a quarter (27%) of studies used a confounder selection approach based on prior knowledge or theory, and a further 3% used a directed acyclic graph. The remaining studies (9%) used only a data-driven approach. Conclusions : Most published studies aiming to estimate the effect of physical activity-related exposures on health-related outcomes do not report the method used to choose confounders. This goes against reporting guidelines and negatively impacts transparency and reproducibility. These results suggest that more awareness and professional development of confounder selection methods are required among people conducting observational studies in physical activity epidemiology and that greater adherence to reporting guidelines is required by study authors, reviewers, and journal editors.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Confounder Selection in Observational Studies in High-Impact Medical and Epidemiological JournalsJAMA Network Open, 2025
- Association of Changes in Physical Activity and Adiposity With Mortality and Incidence of Cardiovascular Disease: Longitudinal Findings From the UK BiobankMayo Clinic Proceedings, 2022
- A systematic review of quantitative bias analysis applied to epidemiological researchInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 2021
- Use of directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) to identify confounders in applied health research: review and recommendationsInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 2020
- Methods for the Selection of Covariates in Nutritional Epidemiology Studies: A Meta-Epidemiological ReviewCurrent Developments in Nutrition, 2019
- A descriptive review of variable selection methods in four epidemiologic journals: there is still room for improvementEuropean Journal of Epidemiology, 2019
- Principles of confounder selectionEuropean Journal of Epidemiology, 2019
- Sample Size Estimation in Prevalence StudiesIndian Journal of Pediatrics, 2012
- Illustrating bias due to conditioning on a colliderInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 2009
- Invited Commentary: Variable Selection versus Shrinkage in the Control of Multiple ConfoundersAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 2007