Comment on “Climate and agricultural land use change impacts on streamflow in the upper midwestern United States,” by Satish C. Gupta et al.
- 15 September 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Water Resources Research
- Vol. 52 (9) , 7523-7528
Abstract
The paper “Climate and agricultural land use change impacts on streamflow in the upper midwestern United States” by Satish C. Gupta, Andrew C. Kessler, Melinda K. Brown, and Francis Zvomuya (hereafter referred to as Gupta et al.) purports to evaluate “the relative importance of changes in precipitation and LULC (land use, land cover) on streamflow in 29 Hydrologic Unit Code 008 watersheds in the Upper Midwestern United States.” However, as we report here, the approach used by Gupta et al. is wholly inadequate for making such an evaluation. Gupta et al. use strong language to criticize other studies and imply a level of certainty that goes well beyond, and in some cases is entirely unsupported by, the results they have presented. We take this opportunity to point out several critical flaws in their study.Keywords
Funding Information
- the National Science Foundation ((ENG 1209445 and 1209402))
- US Department of Agriculture NRCS ((69-3A75-14-269))
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Identifying Sediment Sources and Sinks in the Root River, Southeastern MinnesotaAnnals of the American Association of Geographers, 2013
- Landscape evolution, valley excavation, and terrace development following abrupt postglacial base-level fallGeological Society of America Bulletin, 2013
- The Role of Hydrologic Alteration and Riparian Vegetation Dynamics in Channel Evolution along the Lower Minnesota RiverTransactions of the ASABE, 2013
- Generalized Linear Mixed Models2012
- Landscape evolution in south-central Minnesota and the role of geomorphic history on modern erosional processesGSA Today, 2011
- Large Shift in Source of Fine Sediment in the Upper Mississippi RiverEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2011
- Floodplain width adjustments in response to rapid base level fall and knickpoint migrationGeomorphology, 2011
- Effects of subsurface drainage tiles on streamflow in Iowa agricultural watersheds: Exploratory hydrograph analysisHydrological Processes, 2008
- Adaptation to natural flow regimesTrends in Ecology & Evolution, 2004
- The Abuse of PowerThe American Statistician, 2001