The ideal versus the real: Mismatches in reading instruction for emergent bilinguals in secondary science classrooms
Author:
- 12 June 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Science Education
- Vol. 108 (6) , 1519-1548
Abstract
The emphasis on language and literacy in science education research has urged science teachers to include reading as an integral part of learning science. However, in US secondary schools, the percentage of students reading under grade level is high, and emergent bilinguals (EBs) are significantly represented among this group. While researchers across disciplines have proposed a number of prescriptive reading practices in science classrooms tightly aligned with instructional standards, few scholars have closely examined the starting point of reading instruction in science classrooms, and even fewer have focused on actual instruction for EBs in these classrooms. This study examines the nature of existing reading practices in science classrooms, with a particular focus on EBs. Using a qualitative multiple case study method, this study found significant mismatches between actual classroom practices and the ideal prescriptions about science reading instruction portrayed in educational standards and research. This study also found that teachers were battling numerous obstacles to implementing research/standards‐based prescriptions. With the implications of science reading instruction for EBs' language and science content learning, this article will contribute to developing reading instruction and practices grounded in real classrooms and improving the instructional environment for reading‐inclusive science classrooms.Keywords
This publication has 94 references indexed in Scilit:
- Praxis crisis and the trouble with science teacher education for emergent bilingual learnersScience Education, 2023
- Reframing formative assessment for emergent bilinguals: Linguistically responsive assessing in science classroomsScience Education, 2022
- Why Sociocultural Context Matters in the Science of Reading and the Reading of Science: Revisiting the Science Discovery NarrativeReading Research Quarterly, 2021
- Preservice secondary science teachers’ understanding of academic language: Moving beyond “just the vocabulary”Science Education, 2020
- Science and language integration with English learners: A conceptual framework guiding instructional materials developmentScience Education, 2019
- Reading and Writing as Scientists? Text Genres and Literacy Practices in Girls’ Middle‐Grade ScienceJournal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 2017
- Helping Students Bridge Inferences in Science Texts Using Graphic OrganizersJournal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 2016
- Visual Literacy as a Classroom ApproachJournal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, 2012
- How literacy in its fundamental sense is central to scientific literacyScience Education, 2003
- Index of science reading awareness: An interactive-constructive model, test verification, and grades 4-8 resultsJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1998