Assessing Facilitator Fidelity to Principles of Public Deliberation: Tutorial
Open Access
- 13 December 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Formative Research
- Vol. 7 (1) , e51202
Abstract
Public deliberation, or deliberative democracy, is a method used to elicit informed perspectives and justifiable solutions to ethically fraught or contentious issues that affect multiple stakeholder groups with conflicting interests. Deliberative events bring together stakeholders (deliberants) who are provided with empirical evidence on the central issue or concern and then asked to discuss the evidence, consider the issue from a societal perspective, and collectively work toward a justifiable resolution. There is increasing interest in this method, which warrants clear guidance for evaluating the quality of its use in research. Most of the existing literature on measuring deliberation quality emphasizes the quality of deliberants’ inputs (eg, engagement and evidence of compromise) during deliberative sessions. Fewer researchers have framed quality in terms of facilitator inputs, and these researchers tend to examine inputs that are consistent with generic group processes. The theory, process, and purpose of public deliberation, however, are distinct from those of focus groups or other group-based discussions and warrant a mechanism for measuring quality in terms of facilitator fidelity to the principles and processes of deliberative democracy. In our public deliberation on ethical conflicts in minor consent for biomedical HIV prevention research, we assessed facilitator fidelity to these principles and processes because we believe that such assessments serve as a component of a comprehensive evaluation of overall deliberation quality. We examined verbatim facilitator remarks in the deliberation transcripts and determined whether they aligned with the 6 principles of public deliberation: equal participation, respect for the opinions of others, adoption of a societal perspective, reasoned justification of ideas, expression of diverse opinions, and compromise or movement toward consensus. In this tutorial, we describe the development of a blueprint to guide researchers in assessing facilitator fidelity, share 3 templates that will assist them in the task, and describe the results of our assessment of facilitator fidelity in 1 of the 4 sites in which we conducted deliberations.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Brief Report: Role of Sociobehavioral Factors in Subprotective TFV-DP Levels Among YMSM Enrolled in 2 PrEP TrialsJAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 2019
- Moral conflict and competing duties in the initiation of a biomedical HIV prevention trial with minor adolescentsAJOB Empirical Bioethics, 2016
- Adolescent Self-Consent for Biomedical Human Immunodeficiency Virus Prevention ResearchJournal of Adolescent Health, 2015
- Preexposure Prophylaxis for Adolescents and Young Adults at Risk for HIV Infection: Is an Ounce of Prevention Worth a Pound of Cure?Clinical Infectious Diseases, 2012
- What Is Good Public Deliberation?Hastings Center Report, 2012
- What Is Public Deliberation?Hastings Center Report, 2012
- A Framework for Assessing the Quality of Democratic Deliberation: Enhancing Deliberation as a Tool for BioethicsJournal of Empirical Research on Human Research Ethics, 2011
- Blueprint for a deliberative public forum on biobanking policy: were theoretical principles achievable in practice?Health Expectations, 2011
- Assessing the quality of democratic deliberation: A case study of public deliberation on the ethics of surrogate consent for researchSocial Science & Medicine, 2010
- Three Approaches to Qualitative Content AnalysisQualitative Health Research, 2005