Measuring the Quality of Peer-Reviewed Publications in Social Work: Impact Factors—Liberation or Liability?
- 1 March 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Social Work Education
- Vol. 29 (2) , 120-136
Abstract
Systems for measuring the quality of publications in peer-reviewed academic journals have achieved importance in the ‘audit culture’ to which academia worldwide has become increasingly subjected. In the United Kingdom this debate has focused on government proposals to give greater emphasis to bibliometrics (counts of journal articles and their citations) as a measurement of research quality, in respect of publications in the emergent Research Excellence Framework (REF) which is set to replace the Research Assessment Exercise (RAE). This approach impacts on social work educators who are the main producers of papers published in peer-reviewed academic journals. It affects their publishing behaviour by pressurising them to publish their work in journals that are regarded as being prestigious, for which ‘high impact factor’ journals as determined by Thomson Reuters—a private commercial information management enterprise with headquarters in the United States—has become a proxy for quality. In this paper the authors describe and critique the Thomson Reuters system as it applies to social work and propose an alternate fair, inclusive and transparent system for assessing the quality of publications based on peer evaluation and incorporating an ethical approach consistent with the discipline's professional values.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- The mismeasurement of scienceCurrent Biology, 2007
- Comparing the 1996 and 2001 Research Selectivity Exercises in Respect of Social WorkSocial Work Education, 2007
- PERCEPTIONS OF PROFESSIONAL SOCIAL WORK JOURNALS: FINDINGS FROM A NATIONAL SURVEYJournal of Social Work Education, 2006
- Social work research and the 2001 Research Assessment Exercise: An initial overviewSocial Work Education, 2003
- Developmental Compartments and Planar Polarity in DrosophilaCurrent Biology, 2002
- Results of the Doctoral Faculty Publication ProjectJournal of Social Work Education, 2002
- The 1996 Research Assessment Exercise and the Response of Social Work AcademicsThe British Journal of Social Work, 1998
- Should there be a Moratorium on Articles that Rank Schools of Social Work Based on Faculty Publications? No!Journal of Social Work Education, 1993
- Citation Indexes for ScienceScience, 1955