Perceptions of Risk, Risk Aversion, and Barriers to Adoption of Decision Support Systems and Integrated Pest Management: An Introduction
Authors:
- David H. GentDGDavid H. Gent
- Erick De WolfEWErick De Wolf
- Sarah J. PethybridgeSPSarah J. Pethybridge
Open Access
- 1 June 2011
- journal article
- Published by Scientific Societies in Phytopathology®
- Vol. 101 (6) , 640-643
Abstract
Rational management of plant diseases, both economically and environmentally, involves assessing risks and the costs associated with both correct and incorrect tactical management decisions to determine when control measures are warranted. Decision support systems can help to inform users of plant disease risk and thus assist in accurately targeting events critical for management. However, in many instances adoption of these systems for use in routine disease management has been perceived as slow. The under-utilization of some decision support systems is likely due to both technical and perception constraints that have not been addressed adequately during development and implementation phases. Growers' perceptions of risk and their aversion to these perceived risks can be reasons for the “slow” uptake of decision support systems and, more broadly, integrated pest management (IPM). Decision theory provides some tools that may assist in quantifying and incorporating subjective and/or measured probabilities of disease occurrence or crop loss into decision support systems. Incorporation of subjective probabilities into IPM recommendations may be one means to reduce grower uncertainty and improve trust of these systems because management recommendations could be explicitly informed by growers' perceptions of risk and economic utility. Ultimately though, we suggest that an appropriate measure of the value and impact of decision support systems is grower education that enables more skillful and informed management decisions independent of consultation of the support tool outputs.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Decision Aids for Multiple-Decision Disease Management as Affected by Weather Input ErrorsPhytopathology®, 2011
- Perceptions of Disease Risk: From Social Construction of Subjective Judgments to Rational Decision MakingPhytopathology®, 2011
- Disease Cycle Approach to Plant Disease PredictionAnnual Review of Phytopathology, 2007
- Risk Assessment: Concepts, Development, and Future OpportunitiesPlant Health Progress, 2003
- Bayesian analysis of plant disease predictionPlant Pathology, 2002
- Decision Support Systems: Quenching the ThirstPlant Disease, 2002
- Modelling: the basis for rational disease managementCrop Protection, 2000
- Control of Powdery Mildew Using the UC Davis Powdery Mildew Risk Index.APSnet Feature Articles, 1999
- Simple Decision Aids for Practical Control of PestsPlant Disease, 1984
- A Decision Theoretic Approach to Crop Disease Prediction and ControlAmerican Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1970