A Realist Evaluation of Individual Service Funds for Adults With Intellectual Disabilities Living in England
Open Access
- 1 January 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Health & Social Care in the Community
- Vol. 2026 (1)
Abstract
Background: Individual Service Funds (ISFs) are an innovative way to improve support for adults with learning disabilities in England by enabling highly tailored support that makes use of community resources and adapts quickly to changing needs. Despite this, ISFs are not widely implemented. Where they are used, changes are often superficial, with funding being rebranded without substantive changes to service configuration or delivery, and there is little research evidence to inform their implementation at scale. Methods: This qualitative realist evaluation builds on an initial programme theory of ISFs developed by a participatory realist review. We used semi‐structured interviews and focus groups with a diverse group of participants ( n = 48), including those with experience of developing and using ISFs and those engaged with traditional social care services. Questions explored how initial theories aligned with participants’ perceptions and experiences and sought to elicit additional theories. Analysis was iterative, focusing on developing context‐mechanism‐outcome configurations to identify mechanisms and contextual factors that support or constrain successful use of ISFs. Findings: Findings revealed the dynamic and relational nature of the contexts in which ISFs are implemented. Five interconnected programme theories were identified, operating as continua across system, organisational and individual levels of social care delivery. These theories explain how different contextual factors interact with mechanisms to generate outcomes. The theories address: (1) the development of shared values and understanding between stakeholders; (2) the quality and nature of relationships; (3) the degree of transparency in processes and decision‐making; (4) the extent of restrictions placed on budget use and (5) approaches to risk management and positive risk‐taking. Each theory represents a spectrum of possible configurations rather than binary states, reflecting the fluid and dynamic nature of support provision. Conclusion: We identified five cross‐cutting theory areas that together form a practice‐informed programme theory to guide ISF implementation within complex social care systems.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR151776)
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Debilitating landscapes of care and support: envisaging alternative futuresSocial & Cultural Geography, 2021
- Understanding ‘context’ in realist evaluation and synthesisInternational Journal of Social Research Methodology, 2021
- ‘We’re Giving Them Choice Which Is Controlled Choice’—Care Managers’ Views on Finding Social Care Support for People with Learning DisabilitiesThe British Journal of Social Work, 2019
- Austerity and the lives of people with learning disabilities. A thematic synthesis of current literatureDisability & Society, 2018
- Equity in social care for people with intellectual disabilities? A cross-sectional study examining the distribution of social care funding across local authorities in EnglandHealth & Social Care in the Community, 2016
- Theory-driven evaluation of public health programmes2009
- The Economics of Self‐Directed SupportJournal of Integrated Care, 2007
- CONSUMERS IN CHARGE OF CARE: THE DUTCH PERSONAL BUDGET AND ITS IMPACT ON THE MARKET, PROFESSIONALS AND THE FAMILYEuropean Societies, 2006
- The Impact of Organizational Culture and Reshaping Capabilities on Change Implementation Success: The Mediating Role of Readiness for ChangeJournal of Management Studies, 2005
- WHAT WORKS IN EVALUATION RESEARCH?The British Journal of Criminology, 1994