From Microcars to Heavy-Duty Vehicles: Vehicle Performance Comparison of Battery and Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles
Open Access
Abstract
Low vehicle occupancy rates combined with record conventional vehicle sales justify the requirement to optimize vehicle type based on passengers and a powertrain with zero-emissions. This study compares the performance of different vehicle types based on the number of passengers/payloads, powertrain configuration (battery and fuel cell electric configurations), and drive cycles, to assess range and energy consumption. An adequate choice of vehicle segment according to the real passenger occupancy enables the least energy consumption. Vehicle performance in terms of range points to remarkable results for the FCEV (fuel cell electric vehicle) compared to BEV (battery electric vehicle), where the former reached an average range of 600 km or more in all different drive cycles, while the latter was only cruising nearly 350 km. Decisively, the cost analysis indicated that FCEV remains the most expensive option with base cost three-fold that of BEV. The FCEV showed notable results with an average operating cost of less than 7 cents/km, where BEV cost more than 10 €/km in addition to the base cost for light-duty vehicles. The cost analysis for a bus and semi-truck showed that with a full payload, FCPT (fuel cell powertrain) would be more economical with an average energy cost of ~1.2 €/km, while with BPT the energy cost is more than 300 €/km.Keywords
Funding Information
- Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (CEECIND/02589/2017, 1801P.00962.1.01 - IN+ UIDP/EEA/50009/2020 - IST-ID)
- European Regional Development Fund (LISBOA-01-0247-FEDER-046095)
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Maximum Energy Recovery in Electric Vehicle through Regenerative Braking SystemInternational Journal for Research in Applied Science and Engineering Technology, 2018
- Hybrid battery/supercapacitor energy storage system for the electric vehiclesJournal of Power Sources, 2018
- Fuel cell hybrid electric vehicle (FCHEV): Novel fuel cell/SC hybrid power generation systemEnergy Conversion and Management, 2018
- Energy consumption of auxiliary systems of electric carsMATEC Web of Conferences, 2017
- Influence of temperature on the tyre rolling resistanceInternational Journal of Automotive Technology, 2017
- Analysis of electric vehicle powertrain simulators for fuel consumption calculations2016
- Indirect methodologies to estimate energy use in vehicles: Application to battery electric vehiclesEnergy Conversion and Management, 2016
- Electric vehicle range prediction for constant speed trip using multi-objective optimizationJournal of Power Sources, 2015
- Thermal and electrical experimental characterisation of a 1 kW PEM fuel cell stackInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2013
- The State of the Art of Electric, Hybrid, and Fuel Cell VehiclesProceedings of the IEEE, 2007