Simulations reveal that beta burst detection may inappropriately characterize the beta band
Preprint
Abstract
In neurophysiological research, the traditional view of beta band activity as sustained oscillations is being reinterpreted as transient bursts. Bursts are characterized by a distinct wavelet shape, high amplitude, and, most importantly, brief temporal occurrence. The primary method for their detection relies on a threshold-based analysis of spectral power, and this presents two fundamental issues. First, the threshold selection is effectively arbitrary, being influenced by both temporally proximal and distal factors in the signal. Second, the method necessarily detects temporal events, as such it is susceptible to misidentifying sustained signals as transient bursts. To address these issues, this study systematically explores burst detection through simulations, shedding light on the method’s robustness across various scenarios. Although the method is effective in detecting transients in numerous cases, it can be overly sensitive, leading to spurious detections. Moreover, when applied to simulations featuring exclusively sustained events, the method frequently yields events exhibiting characteristics consistent with a transient burst interpretation. By simulating an average difference in power between experimental conditions, we illustrate how apparent burst rate differences between conditions can emerge even in the absence of actual burst rate disparities, and even in the absence of bursts. This capacity to produce misleading outcomes challenges the reinterpretation of sustained beta oscillations as transient bursts and prompts a critical reassessment of the existing literature. New and Noteworthy: Neurophysiological research is experiencing a transformative shift in understanding beta band activity, moving away from the notion of sustained oscillations towards recognizing the significance of transient bursts. Here we show how the methods to detect such bursts are prone to spurious detections and can blur the distinction between sustained signals and transient bursts. Further, in realistic scenarios these methods can produce apparent behavioral associations where no such association exists.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Journal of Neurophysiology, 134 (1), 10.
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Bursting with Potential: How Sensorimotor Beta Bursts Develop from Infancy to AdulthoodJournal of Neuroscience, 2023
- Age-related differences in transient gamma band activity during working memory maintenance through adolescenceNeuroImage, 2023
- Fronto-central resting-state 15-29 Hz transient beta events change with therapeutic transcranial magnetic stimulation for posttraumatic stress disorder and major depressive disorderScientific Reports, 2023
- Detection and analysis of cortical beta bursts in developmental EEG dataDevelopmental Cognitive Neuroscience, 2022
- Laminar dynamics of high amplitude beta bursts in human motor cortexNeuroImage, 2021
- SciPy 1.0: fundamental algorithms for scientific computing in PythonNature Methods, 2020
- Human motor cortical beta bursts relate to movement planning and response errorsPLOS Biology, 2019
- NeuroDSP: A package for neural digital signal processingJournal of Open Source Software, 2019
- Neural mechanisms of transient neocortical beta rhythms: Converging evidence from humans, computational modeling, monkeys, and miceProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2016
- Identifying neuronal oscillations using rhythmicityNeuroImage, 2015