Abstract
Interpretive frameworks in visual media studies suggest that audiences are active agents in the construction of meaning. As a discipline that emphasizes the value of an interpretive approach, visual anthropology has much to offer by way of informing media advocacy programmes geared towards HIV/Aids education. This paper grapples with the conundrum presented by the agency of audiences to interpret documentary film within the context of the political imperative to send clear messages about HIV/Aids transmission and prevention. The didactic approach to HIV/Aids in documentary film is that messages about safer sex practices, for example, should not be open to interpretation. This paper draws on the methods and theory of visual anthropology to suggest the impossibility of such an agenda. Based on an impact assessment of a documentary film project called Steps for the Future, this paper argues that audiences do not automatically trust the documentary genre, and that audiences are more likely to engage in debate when stories about HIV/Aids convey the complexity of life choices. The paper argues that documentary films that draw on the wisdom of the African dilemma tale offer respect to their audiences’ interpretive abilities and the possibility of breaking the silence around HIV/Aids.

This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit: