“Conducted Properly, Published Incorrectly”: The Evolving Status of Gel Electrophoresis Images Along Instrumental Transformations in Times of Reproducibility Crisis
Open Access
- 11 July 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Berichte Zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte
- Vol. 46 (2-3) , 233-258
Abstract
For the last ten years, within molecular life sciences, the reproducibility crisis discourse has been embodied as a crisis of trust in scientific images. Beyond the contentious perception of “questionable research practices” associated with a digital turn in the production of images, this paper highlights the transformations of gel electrophoresis as a family of experimental techniques. Our aim is to analyze the evolving epistemic status of generated images and its connection with a crisis of trust in images within that field.From the 1980s to the 2000s, we identify two key innovations (precast gels and gel docs) leading to a “two‐tiered” gel electrophoresis with different standardization procedures, different epistemic statuses of the produced images and different ways of generating (dis)trust in images. The first tier, exemplified by differential gel electrophoresis (DIGE), is characterized by specialized devices processing images as quantitative data. The second tier, exemplified by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE), is described as a routine technique making use of image as qualitative “virtual witnessing.” The difference between these two tiers is particularly apparent in the ways images are processed, even though both tiers involve image digitization. Our account thus highlights different views on reproducibility within the two tiers. Comparability of images is insisted upon in the first tier while traceability is expected in the second tier. It is striking that these differences occur not only within the same scientific field, but even within the same family of experimental techniques. In the second tier, digitization entails distrust, whereas it implies a collective sentiment of trust in the first tier.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Drawing a line: Setting guidelines for digital image processing in scientific journal articlesSocial Studies of Science, 2012
- RETRACTED: Probing the MicroRNA and Small Interfering RNA Pathways with Virus-Encoded Suppressors of RNA SilencingThe Plant Cell, 2004
- The evolution of molecular markers — just a matter of fashion?Nature Reviews Genetics, 2004
- The role of bioinformatics in two‐dimensional gel electrophoresisProteomics, 2003
- Melanie II – a third‐generation software package for analysis of two‐dimensional electrophoresis images: I. Features and user interfaceElectrophoresis, 1997
- Difference gel electrophoresis. A single gel method for detecting changes in protein extractsElectrophoresis, 1997
- Superimposing two‐dimensional gels to study genetic variation in malaria parasitesElectrophoresis, 1992
- Software aids for the analysis of 2D gel electrophoresis imagesComputers and Biomedical Research, 1979
- Isoelectric focusing of serum proteins in acrylamide gels followed by electrophoresisClinica Chimica Acta, 1969
- Molecular weight estimation of polypeptide chains by electrophoresis in SDS-polyacrylamide gelsBiochemical and Biophysical Research Communications, 1967