Comparison of phonological and whole-word treatments for two contrasting cases of developmental dyslexia
- 1 December 2007
- journal article
- case report
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Cognitive Neuropsychology
- Vol. 24 (8) , 817-842
Abstract
This study compared the effectiveness of two reading treatment programmes for two contrasting developmental dyslexics. W.B. demonstrated “pure” phonological dyslexia (deficient nonword reading but normal irregular-word reading) and N.S. “pure” surface dyslexia (the converse pattern). Both participants completed: (a) a phonological programme, which targeted the sublexical reading procedure through repeated exposure to word “families” with the same grapheme–phoneme correspondence (GPC; e.g., frail, raid, bait); and (b) a whole-word programme, which targeted the lexical reading procedure through tasks that emphasize whole-word visual analysis (e.g., speeded identification of visually degraded words). Both participants improved after training on the targeted words and/or GPCs. However, W.B. demonstrated reliable generalization only following the phonological programme and only in his reading of nonwords. In contrast, N.S. showed generalization across all types of word materials following both programmes. Although the whole-word programme (in particular the degraded-images technique) resulted in numerically greater improvement for N.S., this difference was not significant. Practical and theoretical implications of these results are discussed.Keywords
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- New norms for comparing children's lexical and nonlexical reading: A further look at subtyping dyslexiaAustralian Journal of Psychology, 1999
- Skilled Reading with Impaired Phonology: A Case StudyCognitive Neuropsychology, 1996
- Developmental Phonological Dyslexia: Real Word Reading Can Be Completely NormalCognitive Neuropsychology, 1996
- Surface Dyslexia and Surface Dysgraphia: Treatment Studies and Their Theoretical ImplicationsCognitive Neuropsychology, 1996
- Cognitive Correlates of Developmental Surface Dyslexia: A Single Case StudyCognitive Neuropsychology, 1996
- A dissociation between developmental surface and phonological dyslexia in two undergraduate studentsNeuropsychologia, 1995
- Developmental surface dyslexia: a case study of the efficacy of a remediation programmeCognitive Neuropsychology, 1995
- Visual Memory Deficits: A Plausible Cause of Developmental Dyslexia? Evidence from a Single Case StudyCognitive Neuropsychology, 1991
- Lexical Capture: A Developmental Disorder of Reading and SpellingThe Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section A, 1989
- Patterns of paralexia: A psycholinguistic approachJournal of Psycholinguistic Research, 1973